I originally posted this in the old thread, as a reply to 3 comments from Tarah, Brianna and Katie.
Lewis's Law is a decent point here (also, pardon me, I'm going to reply to all 3 of you in this post) but I genuinely wonder if the problem isn't being perpetuated by people who
mean well, but aren't capable, or people who
seem
capable but genuinely don't mean well. It's definitely true that there's an extremely hostile anti-feminist environment. It's also definitely true that there are some extremely hostile feminists as well; even within the community, terms like TERF ("Trans-exclusionary radical feminist") have risen up in order to try to establish some feminists as engaging in the "wrong kind" of feminism. A major problem I see here comes from the fact that it takes many
to build something but only one person to destroy it. There's definitely some crazy people out there who represent
themselves as feminists. I see a lot of these people dogpiling others and engaging in damaging rhetoric, whether that rhetoric is simply poisonous or just woefully ignorant. A lot of the people (broadly) who comment on these kinds of things are outsiders looking in; they don't understand that other people might not understand the problems
as they're stated. Often I see it said that, "We need more women in tech!". Someone will ask "Why?" and the responses are often filled with vitriol. This is an excellent way to turn someone into an anti-feminist, because they begin associating feminism with the vitriol they received.
I think we definitely need feminism. I don't think feminism is a bad thing, I think it's a very good thing. I do wonder, however, if a lot of people we
perceive
to be anti-female are actually just anti-(what they perceive to be)-feminism. If my perception of feminism was nothing but a bunch of people who talk about castrating/killiing/etc. all men, I think I'd be rather anti-feminist as well.
Like I said,
do you think some of the anti-feminist rhetoric we see in tech (and even more broadly) is the result of this? I do wonder, very deeply, if maybe the actions of an aggressive minority are breeding an aggressive counterculture, which in turn is reinforcing the original aggressive minority.