/
    You’re viewing the Guardian’s new website. We’d love to hear what you think.
    Skip to main content
    Advertisement
    Hier klicken!

    Benedict Cumberbatch apologises after calling black actors 'coloured'

    Oscar nominee says he was an ‘idiot’ to use the phrase – ironically in a discussion about the lack of opportunities for non-white actors
    Benedict Cumberbatch has apologized.
    Benedict Cumberbatch has apologised. Photograph: Anthony Harvey/Getty Images
    Benedict Cumberbatch has apologised after referring to black actors as “coloured” during an interview on US television, saying he is “devastated” to have caused offence.
    The Sherlock actor said he was “an idiot” after he used the phrase during a debate, ironically about the diversity problems that black British actors face in the UK compared to the US, which he argued has been more open to casting them.
    Talking on the Tavis Smiley show on PBS, Cumberbatch said: “I think as far as coloured actors go, it gets really different in the UK, and a lot of my friends have had more opportunities here [in America] than in the UK, and that’s something that needs to change.”
    Reaction was mixed after the actor – who has been nominated for an Oscar for his role in The Imitation Game – used the outdated term, with many praising the sentiment of his argument but lamenting his poor choice of words.
    A spokesperson for the anti-racism charity Show Racism the Red Card, told the Independent: “Benedict Cumberbatch has highlighted a very important issue within the entertainment industry and within society. In doing so, he has also inadvertently highlighted the issue of appropriate terminology and the evolution of language.”
    They added that the organisation feels the term “has the potential to cause offence due to the connotations associated with the term and its historical usage”.
    In a statement Cumberbatch said: “I’m devastated to have caused offence by using this outmoded terminology. I offer my sincere apologies. I make no excuse for my being an idiot and know the damage is done.”
    Cumberbatch found himself in a race controversy last year, when Stacey Cumberbatch, the city commissioner in New York, told the New York Times that she believed Cumberbatch’s fifth great-grandfather had owned her ancestors, who were held at a sugar plantation in Barbados.
    Advertisement
    The actor has spoken about his family’s past as slave owners and revealed that his mother once advised him to not use his name professionally in case of reparations claims by the descendants of slaves.
    The PBS debate came at a time when British actors are enjoying high-profile success in Hollywood. Last year Chiwetel Ejiofor was nominated for an Oscar for his portrayal of Solomon Northup in 12 Years a Slave – in which Cumberbatch co-starred. This year David Oyelowo has won praise for his performance in Ava DuVernay’s film Selma.
    Many black British actors have found that opportunities in the States have far exceeded those at home. Idris Elba’s career took off after he crossed the Atlantic for a role as Baltimore’s cerebral drug dealer Stringer Bell in The Wire, while Thandie Newton, Carmen Ejogo and Naomie Harris have all taken leading roles in American films and TV shows.
    Last year in the UK, Lenny Henry spoke out about the lack of non-white people working in television and called for channels to reflect the country’s ethnically diverse population.

    comments (2287)

    Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion.
    This discussion is closed for comments.
    We’re doing some maintenance right now. You can still read comments, but please come back later to add your own.
    Commenting has been disabled for this account (why?)
    • Guardian Pick
      I don't doubt that the use of this word is offensive. Its just that it was a mistake. People aren't perfect. I would say the intention behind a word is far worse than a word in its self.
      Jump to comment
    • Guardian Pick
      The arrogance of white people who say they are 'not offended' by the use of the term 'coloured.'
      It is not about you.
      Jump to comment
    • Guardian Pick
      I don't see the issue with the use of the word coloured to describe people of colour.
      I myself am brown, if a person were to use the word coloured as a general term for all people of colour to highlight the issue of a lack of diversity in British media, I am not offended by the word or message. If a person were to use the word coloured as general term to say something offensive about the group, then the message would be offensive, rather than the…
      Jump to comment
    • Guardian Pick
      Language evolves. It's a little dishonest to appeal to the etymology of an offensive word in order to give it's usage a pass.
      Jump to comment
    1 2 3 4 43 next
    Loading comments… Trouble loading?
    • 190 191
      Damn, is my public school education showing?
      Reply |
      • 88 89
        Excellent point.
        I wonder how many minorities there actually are at Harrow?
        Thats the big problem with an English boarding school. You probably get a great education but you end up sharing a dormitory and spending all your time with the worst pack of wankers in the world. Some of that is bound to rub off on even the nicest people.
        Reply |
      • 47 48
        There are probably quite a few sons of African diplomats at Britain's most elite public schools. Then again, who knows how much racial abuse/condescension they have to put up with.
        Reply |
      • 145 146
        Unfortunately I think this is your prejudice (or at the least lack of knowledge) showing
        Public schools attract many foreign students and so those at them get exposed to numerous races and cultures. This to me just seems like a language slip, many are niave over things like this
        Reply |
    • 74 75
      And there's me thinking each and every one of us was coloured. Supposed it depends what shade?
      Reply |
    • 333 334
      Looks like a non issue. Who took offence? Some people at twitter?
      Reply |
      • 138 139
        Some white publicly educated people on Twitter.
        Reply |
      • 46 47
        The anti-racism charity Show Racism The Red Card - which you'd know if you bothered to read the article. Sheesh.
        Reply |
      • 202 203
        did you read the article? Here is what Show Racism The Red Card said
        Benedict Cumberbatch has highlighted a very important issue within the entertainment industry and within society. In doing so, he has also inadvertently highlighted the issue of appropriate terminology and the evolution of language
        Does that really sound like "taking offense" to you? To me it sounds like a careful and constructive criticism, not offense at all. Sheesh.
        Reply |
    • 47 48
      Surely coloured just refers to non-whites including black people Asian Chinese and anyone on the spectrum? Or have I just got it totally wrong also?
      Reply |
      • 31 32
        White is also a colour.
        Reply |
      • 65 66
        Everyone is coloured. To use the term 'coloured' to refer to non-white people suggests that white people are in some way not 'coloured' and therefore different. While they might be different, in that everyone is different, it sets white people aside and suggests that they are somehow free from colour which they are not.
        Reply |
      • 43 44
        because white people have a colour too. Splitting the world like that assumes that white people are 'it' and everyone else is in a category called 'other'.
        Reply |
    • 149 150
      But why do Americans think "people of colour" is an okay term to use? One of those phrases that are inexplicably still considered politically correct, like "third world".
      Reply |
      • 11 12
        That's a good question. Everyone is a person of colour surely?
        Reply |
      • 3 4
        It's a useful term though, yer 'Third World'. Obviously a bit of the context has been lost now the Second World has been basically absorbed into the other two.
        Perhaps Second World should come back, but slightly redefined.
        Reply |
      • 5 6
        Um, how would that be relevant to black people in the US or UK, then. They're living in "first world" countries. They still often fail to get the same opportunities as the paler-coloured people.
        Reply |
    • 268 269
      Genuine question. Why is the adjective "coloured" offensive but the adjectival phrase "person of colour" considered to be acceptable?
      And what about the National Association for the Advancement of Coloured People? They've kept their civil rights era name; do they get a free pass?
      And who decides all this anyway?
      Reply |
    • 18 19
      Maybe he meant non-white rather than just black, there are pleanty of British actors of Indian descent working in the US.
      Reply |
    • 10 11
      Oh what a surprise. Look at his ancestors...
      Reply |
    • 37 38
      Quick, teacup needed!
      Reply |
    • 9 10
      Is this even news in the US, where he said it? I can't see any news articles on it.
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 14 15
      I just found that above an article about a new group for so named coloured children. The apparently also "coloured" author needs to apologise now,too. You cannot say something right if you are white...although Cumberbatch would already look out of colour where I live. Too dark.
      Reply |
    • 184 185
      I can't see what the issue is with this word, and never had. It's not as though he said "them there cotton pickin' coloured folk" in a Southern redneck accent.
      If he had said "black", then someone from the Indian/Chinese/Papua New Guinean Actors' Guild would have been offended. If he had said "non-white", those with partial white heritage might have taken umbrage. If he had said "persons of colour", he would have sounded like a sanctimonious twit.
      Why can't people just acknowledge the gesture and spirit of his statement without getting themselves in a lather? Hmm. I guess if we all applied the same common sense quite a few people in the race industry would be out of a job.
      Reply |
      • 33 34
        You know, I wouldn't like being called a "Mick". I have predominantly Irish ancestry. So if someone persistently called me that, despite my asking them not to, for years, I'd think they were being cretinous.
        It's exactly the same with African American people (and others). THEY (fairly universally) have said they don't like it. So don't do it! It doesn't actually matter what you think - it's simple politeness to use the terms that people prefer.
        I hate religion, and yet I would address the Pope as "your Holiness" if I were introduced. And that's not a term that has outright negative connotations (where you're saying someone has a different skin shade to you, while completely managing to ignore their actual cultural background).
        Reply |
      • 48 49
        It's a little bit different though in that "Mick" is not a visual identifier. And yes, overuse of this term would be cretinous in the extreme - particularly when "Irish guy" works a whole lot better.
        I have always thought that we are unnecessarily walking on eggshells with the black thing. I mean, must people really be expected to second guess every situation? Of course, Cucumberpatch could have replaced "coloured" with "black, brown, Indian, Chinese, etc. etc. etc.", but that would be been not only mealy-mouthed but utterly pretentious and dull. He would have then had a self-appointed representative of some group that he hadn't mentioned crawling out of their little corner to play the race card.
        It really is tiresome, and I am speaking as someone who didn't give a rat's arse about occasionally being called "the coloured guy" at school.
        Reply |
      • 49 50
        I was once corrected by a London waitress when she asked me how I'd like my coffee and I said "black" (in Africa this is always followed up with "and sweet, like me!") - gave me a full-on glare and said acidly "you mean: 'without milk'"
        Yes, of course I bloody did.
        Reply |
    • 6 7
      Simply a reflection of his upbringing.
      Reply |
      • 36 37
        ? i work with a very definitely working class northerner who left school age 16 and is in his early 50s. He always says 'coloured' rather than black (leading to the rest of us saying what colour, pink, green?). I think you'll find the word is used by people from many different backgrounds...
        Reply |
      • 63 64
        A lot of people of that generation tended to use the word 'coloured' because it was a damned sight politer than the alternatives.
        Still, enjoy the moral high ground while you can, because when you hit your early 50s you can be sure there'll be another generation of sanctimonious attention-seekers desperate to point out how 'on-message' they are, and how your, once perfectly sincere, choice of words marks you as a racist.
        Reply |
      • 7 8
        Then he was a influenced by his upbringing. I guess it's true the 'posh' have more in common with the 'working class' than the liberal middle classes do.
        Reply |
    • 142 143
      OMG...who, I mean who could take offence at what he said?. Can't people differentiate between intent, context, and racism
      Reply |
    • 25 26
      Mixed feelings about this. 'Coloured' is a stupid term that I'm honestly amazed Cumberbatch didn't realise was offensive and completely outdated; it's something I was taught when I was a kid.
      On the other hand, I hope the actor's well-intentioned and considered point about the lack of diversity within the arts, particularly the UK, isn't overshadowed by this foolish error.
      Reply |
    • 10 11
      It's offensive because it assumes the position that white is the standard and anything else is foreign or different. White is a colour too.
      Reply |
      • 35 36
        I think you will find that neither black nor white are technically colours. Black is ironically the absence of colour while white reflects all visible light and so could be seen as the colours together.
        Reply |
      • 22 23
        (BBC)
        'The term was common parlance in the 1960s, but its origins are the problem, says Mr Agbetu. It comes from the ideology of racism, that white people are white, and everyone else is somehow other coloured. It fails to recognise that everyone has an ethnicity and is an inadequate "one-size-fits all" description. '
        It hasn't stopped half the world simply referring to white people as 'whites' and ignoring their ethnicity, though.
        Reply |
      • 19 20
        Yes if one was being pedantic you are correct. Except I've never met an actual black person or a white person. I mean as a white person I'm more of a pink/yellow tone and my black daughter is a sort of orangey brown.
        Reply |
    • 94 95
      Actor "devasted" after calling a particular group goodness-knows-what, since what was Ok to call them last week (decided by who, btw?) is out this week in favour of something you're gonna be hung for next week, and now the PR machine is all in a spin. What an absolute load of bollox. NEXT!
      Reply |
    • This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.
    • 18 19
      If he'd said "people of colour" he'd have been fine.
      Reply |
    • 87 88
      So its OK for Halle Berry to accept her Oscar on behalf of women of colour? Does the 'ed' really cause offence. The world has gone fucking mad!
      Sod it, I can't fathom this crazy PC maze of nonsense, so I'll just say what I see from now on, wonder how long I'll last...
      Reply |
      • 27 28
        "Sod it, I can't fathom this crazy PC maze of nonsense, so I'll just say what I see from now on, wonder how long I'll last..."
        I tend to agree. This kind of trivia is bad in two ways: Firstly it detracts from the real-world racism - which primarily manifests economically and with the denial of opportunities and with the theft or resources and western support for corrupt despots on a global level; and secondly because it plays into the hands of those who harbour prejudice and feel that the 'PC brigade' is trying to police our language.
        From the context it should be clear that this is trivia and the apology adequately puts the matter to rest. Personally I'd rather have an end put to the widespread, everyday use of truly offensive racist terms in schools, forums, youtube comments etc.
        Reply |
      • 5 6
        Helle berry is mixed race scouse. Mother from Liverpool.
        Reply |
      • 6 7
        Scouse? Now you are just being offensive.
        Reply |
    • 33 34
      It's good that this article is open to comments. We'll possibly get a definitive answer to the issues raised.
      Reply |
      • 2 3
        You've got the full spectrum of feedback.
        From the "I'm not a racist but I says whats I like!" bigots to the "leave 'em alone!" hipsters, to the facetious pseudo-scientists who believe that "white/black isn't a colour so, you know, get over it".
        Just another day behind a keyboard!
        Reply |
    • 37 38
      Gag him, strike him and make him pay! This is an outrage. Give me bloody strength, what a pathetic nation/world it's becoming.
      Reply |
    • 3 4
      I think as far as coloured actors go, it gets really different in the UK, and a lot of my friends have had more opportunities here [in America] than in the UK,
      That's a bit appalling.
      Reply |
    • 67 68
      NAACP - the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.
      UNCF - United Negro College Fund
      Lord save us from bigots AND political correctness.
      Reply |
    1 2 3 4 43 next
    1. Popular in culture
    2. Popular across the guardian
    Advertisement
    SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
    SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone. See the Facebook Help Center for more information.
    desktop
    0%
    10%
    20%
    30%
    40%
    50%
    60%
    70%
    80%
    90%
    100%