• Regular
  • Medium
  • Large
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

30 Years Later, Suffering Continues in Bhopal

An aerial photo taken in September shows a slum in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India, near the site of the Union Carbide pesticide plant involved in one of the worst industrial accidents in history. On Dec. 3, 1984, a gas leak occurred at the plant, exposing more than half a million people to toxic gas and chemicals.
An aerial photo taken in September shows a slum in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India, near the site of the Union Carbide pesticide plant involved in one of the worst industrial accidents in history. On Dec. 3, 1984, a gas leak occurred at the plant, exposing more than half a million people to toxic gas and chemicals. Elena del Estal
Sifon, 16, and Aman, 14, who both suffer from cerebral paralysis, wash their feet on Nov. 11.
Sifon, 16, and Aman, 14, who both suffer from cerebral paralysis, wash their feet on Nov. 11. Elena del Estal
Amna, 4, who has cerebral palsy, watches other children play basketball on Oct. 11. Cerebral palsy can affect brain and nervous system functions, such as movement, hearing, seeing and thinking.
Amna, 4, who has cerebral palsy, watches other children play basketball on Oct. 11. Cerebral palsy can affect brain and nervous system functions, such as movement, hearing, seeing and thinking. Elena del Estal
Alfia, 6, who suffers from a hearing impairment, prays before eating lunch at Chingari Trust in Bhopal on Oct. 11. Chingari Trust is an NGO that offers free medical treatment, rehabilitation and other forms of livelihood support to the children and survivors of the 1984 gas disaster.
Alfia, 6, who suffers from a hearing impairment, prays before eating lunch at Chingari Trust in Bhopal on Oct. 11. Chingari Trust is an NGO that offers free medical treatment, rehabilitation and other forms of livelihood support to the children and survivors of the 1984 gas disaster. Elena del Estal
Sambhavna Clinic offers free medical care to gas leak victims, seen here in August.
Sambhavna Clinic offers free medical care to gas leak victims, seen here in August. Elena del Estal
Children who attend school and therapy through Chingari Trust line up for a meal on Nov. 11.
Children who attend school and therapy through Chingari Trust line up for a meal on Nov. 11. Elena del Estal
Goats and buffalo that provide milk to Bhopal residents graze on land near the abandoned pesticide plant in September.
Goats and buffalo that provide milk to Bhopal residents graze on land near the abandoned pesticide plant in September. Elena del Estal
The pesticide factory was abandoned after the gas leak. Neither Union Carbide nor the government cleaned up the abandoned site.
The pesticide factory was abandoned after the gas leak. Neither Union Carbide nor the government cleaned up the abandoned site. Elena del Estal
of
SHOW CAPTION HIDE CAPTION
fullscreen

In the early morning hours of Dec. 3, 1984, a gas leak occurred at a pesticide plant run by Union Carbide in India, resulting in one of the worst industrial accidents in history.

The people living near the plant in Bhopal didn’t know how to protect themselves as tons of deadly methyl isocyanate gas poured into the air, exposing more than half a million to the toxic fumes. Staying inside and using a wet cloth as a face cover could have saved hundreds. Thousands died, and thousands more were left injured or disabled.

A Union Carbide placard hangs on a building of the abandoned plant. ENLARGE
A Union Carbide placard hangs on a building of the abandoned plant. Elena del Estal

Union Carbide, a U.S. company acquired in 2001 by Dow Chemical Co. , settled with the Indian government in 1989 to pay $470 million to the victims, but did not address environmental hazards tied to the leak. No action has been taken to clean up hazardous waste left at the site, which residents say continues to contaminate soil and water supplies, although no scientific data is available to confirm this claim.

Union Carbide has denied negligence, maintaining that the gas leak was the result of sabotage by a disgruntled employee.

The settlement put the Indian government in charge of deciding who among the claimants should receive payouts and for distributing the compensation.

Thirty years later, survivors and activists have told The Associated Press that thousands of the children in Bhopal born to parents exposed to the gas leak or poisoned by contaminated water have a higher incidence of birth defects than in neighboring urban areas. Skin, vision and breathing disorders are also prevalent. The Indian government told the AP that to date at least 500,000 people have been affected by the disaster, suffering direct injuries or birth defects blamed on the leak, with another estimated 15,000 dead.

The government of Madhya Pradesh state, where Bhopal is located, has denied that these birth defects are linked to the gas leak, but it has built hospitals and provided housing to many survivors, according to Reuters.

Research on the chronic or trans-generational effects on humans exposed to methyl isocyanate gas is limited. The link between the gas leak and birth defects in later generations cannot be confirmed, but several studies published by the scientific community have found higher incidences of genetic abnormalities, miscarriages and still births in Bhopal than in nearby urban areas not exposed to methyl isocyanate gas.

Photographer Elena del Estal, who lives in Delhi, India, spent the past few months documenting some of the residents of Bhopal, many of whom are living with severe health complications.

She said that Chingari Trust, a local nongovernment organization that has documented the ailments of 700 registered children, offers free therapy and classes catered toward disabilities including cerebral palsy, intellectual disability and hearing impairment.

Momazed, 11, who suffers cerebral paralysis and multi deformities in his body, plays with other children on Nov. 11. ENLARGE
Momazed, 11, who suffers cerebral paralysis and multi deformities in his body, plays with other children on Nov. 11. Elena del Estal
  • Regular
  • Medium
  • Large
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn
  • Print
7 comments
suren rao
suren rao subscriber

$470 million, almost half a Billion 30 years ago was a lot of money, if the Indian government had handled that compensation in a manner benefiting the victims of the tragedy. However, as everything else in India it probably went into the pockets of a few well connected individuals and the victims got nothing. Now the Indian government wants to treat it as a criminal act and prosecute the executives of Dow Chemical (that bought Union Carbide). I do not believe the Indian management of the plant were prosecuted. With that attitude it gets no cooperation from the US government or Dow Chemical. The victims remain the victims. A very sad and tragic story to say the least.

Joseph Lyman
Joseph Lyman subscriber

actually, it's not a complicated story.


for starters, read Five Past Midnight In Bhopal for the best treatment i've seen about what actually happened.  there was no sabotage.  and the number of people killed was probably 12-15 thousand, not the fairly ridiculous 3000 on the company website.


between union carbide's failure to accept responsibility (which was almost exclusively theirs for the accident) and the general inability of the indian government to administer emergency and then post-accident forms of relief, the victims received basically nothing.  


the fact that the plant remains in a chernobyl-like state of disaster is a testament to corporate care-lessness and government incompetence.


we live in a consequence-free age.  no one loses their job, goes to jail, or pays any real price for their actions.  sadly, it's only getting worse.

Solomon Neuhardt
Solomon Neuhardt subscriberprofilePrivate

This article seems to get cut off on the website??

Raymond Klett
Raymond Klett subscriber

Your information is not completely accurate. The Indian government owned 51 percent of the plant. I worked for UC at the time but more importantly I was in the army reserve and we had an active real time Intel collection going on. There was concern the incident was sabotage.

Why the media never revealed the true ownership is understandable since Rajiv Ghandi and his predecessor was leaning left and toward the USSR.

So "handing over the keys" isn't correct since India owned more than half. More than likely the employee in question was simply inept.

How the corruption of their government actions dealt with those people is reprehensible.

Another case of lightweight WSJ reporting.

Rocco Papalia
Rocco Papalia subscriber

@Joseph Lyman UC forked over $470M and handed the keys to the plant to the Indian government ... as the Indian government wanted.  Was this enough?  Who is to say?  But the notion that there were 'no consequences' is simply false and the fact that the Indian government has left the plant in place is hardly a testament to 'corporate' carelessness.

Show More Archives

Popular on WSJ

Editors’ Picks

vs