I helped shut down an abortion debate between two men because my uterus isn't up for their discussion

The idea that in a free society absolutely everything should be open to debate has a detrimental effect on marginalised groups

Share

"Last year in Britain, over 185,000 abortions were carried out. What does this say about our national culture?"

This is the opening of the description of an event widely circulated at Oxford University last week. It was a debate entitled "This House Believes Britain’s Abortion Culture Hurts Us All", hosted by the pro-life group Oxford Students for Life. "[Is abortion] a sign of equality, or does it suggest we treat human life carelessly?" the promotional material for the event asks.

Instead of inviting women to speak, the group decided that two men — Timothy Stanley and Brendan O'Neil — and were better placed to discuss the issue. They thought it was appropriate to let men discuss if and when women should be able to make fundamental decisions about their own bodies. Neither will ever have to consider having an abortion. As you can imagine, those of us with uteruses were incredibly angry that they were able to speak for and over us.

READ MORE
Abortion is safe, and it should be as available as easily as contraception
Ireland's refusal to provide a safe abortion to a suicidal rape victim is a national shame

After a backlash and cancellation of the proposed event, OSFL released a statement defending their decision. Feminists are all too used to encountering its indignant assertion that "Free speech is a vital principle of a democratic society." But cancelling the debate is not a violation of free speech; myself and other undergraduates do not have the power to actually censor. Pro-life groups have plenty of platforms to air their views — and in light of the cancellation I’m confident that OSFL will not fail to do so.

A screenshot of the debate's event page on Facebook A screenshot of the debate's event page on Facebook

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The idea that in a free society absolutely everything should be open to debate has a detrimental effect on marginalised groups. Debating abortion as if its a topic to be mulled over and hypothesised on ignores the fact that this is not an abstract, academic issue. It may seem harmless for men like Stanley and O'Neil to debate how and if abortion hurts them; it’s clearly harder for people to see that their words and views might hurt women.

Access to abortion impacts the lives of women, trans and non-binary people every day, and the threat pro-life groups pose to our bodily autonomy is real, not rhetorical. If you don’t believe me, visit any abortion clinic and witness the sustained aggressions of pro-life pickets.

In organizing against this event, I did not stifle free speech. As a student, I asserted that it would make me feel threatened in my own university; as a woman, I objected to men telling me what I should be allowed to do with my own body.

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Argyll Scott International: Commercial Finance Business Partner

£6,000 Car, 10% Bonus, Benefits: Argyll Scott International: Argyll Scott is c...

Austen Lloyd: Commercial Property Solicitor - Northampton

Excellent Salary: Austen Lloyd: NORTHAMPTON - An exciting opportunity for a So...

SThree: Trainee Recruitment Consultant - SThree Group - Leeds

£18000 - £23000 per annum + Uncapped Commission: SThree: SThree Group has been...

SThree: Trainee Recruitment Consultant - SThree Group - Dublin - €25k

£15975.85 - £18531.51 per annum + Uncapped Commission: SThree: SThree Group ha...

Day In a Page

Read Next
David Cameron inspects the Federation Guard in Canberra  

Did Cameron develop his fatal flaw from the late Uncle Bill?

Matthew Norman
London's financial district  

Could more female arts graduates in the City have averted the banking crisis?

Rosie Millard
An Orwellian nightmare in Bedfordshire: my undercover tour of notorious Yarl’s Wood

An Orwellian nightmare in Bedfordshire

My undercover tour of notorious Yarl’s Wood
Interstellar - or inaudible?

Interstellar - or inaudible?

In space, no one can hear you speak, if Nolan gets his way
The model of misogyny?

The model of misogyny?

Should we be offended or fascinated by Allen Jones's objectification of women?
It's time that The Sun’s Page 3 went the same way as Dapper Laughs

It is time Page 3 went the same way as Dapper Laughs

The feature was the concept of The Sun's first editor, Larry Lamb
The three-parent baby trap - is new IVF technique safe?

The three-parent baby trap

Is new IVF technique safe?
War with Isis: Islamic militants have army of 200,000, claims Kurdish leader

Exclusive: Isis have army of 200,000, claims Kurdish leader

CIA has hugely underestimated the number of jihadis, who now rule an area the size of Britain, reports Patrick Cockburn
Rochester by-election: The gloves are off as the Tories and Ukip do battle by the Medway

The gloves are off in the battle for Rochester

The Kentish town has always gone its own way, and this week's by-election is its chance to scoff at the establishment
Michael Cashman: The rainbow warrior

Michael Cashman: The rainbow warrior

Stardom, power, heartbreak, and now crowned Britain's most influential LGBT figure... but the Labour peer says there's so much still to do
Ugandan girls giving up education in hope of being provided for – by paedophiles

Ugandan girls giving up education in hope of being provided for – by paedophiles

The acceptance of cross-generational sex as normal in parts of East Africa is condemning adolescents to terrible consequences
Islam Karimov: The Uzbek dictator who has locked up his pop diva daughter

The dictator who has locked up his pop diva daughter

A student in Britain has called on his grandfather to free his mother
Woolly mammoth cloning war: Scientists divided over the ethics of attempting to revive extinct mammal

Woolly mammoth cloning war

Scientists divided over the ethics of attempting to revive extinct mammal
Ypres toasts the memory of the men who raised a smile in the trenches

Ypres toasts the memory of the men who raised a smile in the trenches

The First World War 'Wipers Times' is commemorated by the opening of a Belgian brewery in the ramparts of the once ruined city
Someone tell President Obama he lost the midterms

Someone tell the President he lost

Obama seems fired up by defeat, and has ploughed ahead on climate change, the internet... and now immigration, says Rupert Cornwell
Author Steve Cole on reinventing James Bond in his new book Shoot to Kill

How do you reinvent the world's most famous secret agent?

Steve Cole on his new James Bond book 'Shoot to Kill'
Public schools: the answer to social immobility

The answer to social immobility

Public schools will never be abolished, so why not put them to work for the national good, asks DJ Taylor