Login using your social network
Login using your Newspass account
- Subscribe now for full access
- Subscribe
Activity
render anonymous hover thing here...
Discover news, sport and entertainment with your friends on our network.
Login with one of your favourite social networks to get started:
Facebook
Log in or sign up
to discover news, sport and entertainment with your friends on our network.
Your Friends' Activity
render anonymous hover thing here...
Last Updated:
October 28, 2014
Your Recommmended
Your History
Hey , there are no items in your Reading List!
You can click on the
icon on stories to add them to your Reading List.
They will stay in this list until you delete them.
They will stay in this list until you delete them.
Your Quick Links
My News
Join today to start using My News and make the most of The Daily Telegraph+ web and mobile sites
- ✔Save articles to read later
- ✔Faster access to the news that interests you
- ✔Easier to share the articles you enjoyed
My Reading List
Save any story to read later on your PC, tablet or mobile
My History
Access to stories you've read so you can find and share them easily
My Quick Links
Quick access to all your favourite parts of our siteNews
Help wanted in Sydney boutique Alice’s Diary ... but only if you’re Korean
- by: Sarah Crawford
- From: The Daily Telegraph
- October 20, 2014 12:00AM
Share
Save this story
The sign in the window of Alice’s Diary / Picture: Chris McKeen
Source:
News Limited
NON-Koreans need not apply.
That is the message from one central Sydney retailer that may have breached the NSW Anti-Discrimination Act with its “Korean speakers only” employment policy.
Fashion and beauty store Alice’s Diary in the heart of Koreatown, on Liverpool Street, is advertising for “Korean staff” at their World Square shop.
Two non-Korean Daily Telegraph staff members who tried to test their employment policy by inquiring about the job were turned away, one in less than two minutes.
The shop could be breaching the NSW Anti-Discrimination Act, which makes it illegal for an employer to use race as a deciding factor in who should be offered a job.
Daily Telegraph reporter Ashlee Mullany visited the shop on Friday after they posted a “Korean Staff Wanted” sign in their window.
Ashlee Mullany.
Source:
News Corp Australia
Rebecca Gredley.
Source:
News Limited
When Mullany asked a shop assistant in the store about the job she was asked: “Is she Korean?”
The reporter explained she was applying for the job, not a friend.
The shop assistant told her they needed someone who spoke Korean but didn’t bother to see if Mullany could speak the language.
“We have lots of Asian customers and, some of them, their English is worse than mine,” she said.
When Daily Telegraph staff member Rebecca Gredley inquired about the job, she was also asked if she spoke Korean or Chinese.
Ashlee Mullany applies for a job at Alice’s Diary / Picture: Chris McKeen.
Source:
DailyTelegraph
The shop assistant was surprised when Gredley said she spoke some Chinese and told her that she may be called for an interview which would be partially conducted in that language.
When she asked if they would employ someone with extensive retail skills but who spoke only English, Gredley was told “probably not”.
Australian Retailers Association executive director Russell Zimmerman said he understood the shop needed staff who spoke the majority of their customers’ language but could be going too far.
“To ask job applicants for a particular language would be reasonable but if they are saying you have to be Korean, that would be a huge issue,” he said.
Anti-Discrimination Board president Dr Stepan Kerkyasharian said any business employing people of a particular race would breach the Act, except if they had applied for and had been granted an exemption.
Race Discrimination Commissioner Dr Tim Soutphommasane said it was unlawful to refuse someone employment because of their race, colour, ethnicity or national origin.
“It is also unlawful to treat any person seeking employment less favourably because of their race. There are exceptions for “special measures”,” Dr Soutphommasane said.
“It is unacceptable for any business to advertise for a position for employees with race as a criterion.
“No member of the Australian community is immune from the law. Everyone is entitled to equal treatment, regardless of their race or ethnic background.”
The Australian Human Rights Commission received 168 complaints about racial discrimination in the workplace in 2012-13.
WHAT THE LAW SAYS:
The NSW Anti-Discrimination Act makes it illegal for an employer to use race as a deciding factor in determining who should be offered employment, and on what terms the job is offered. Exceptions to this rule exist in welfare jobs that are targeted to help a person of a particular race, and in acting, modelling or hospitality jobs where people of a certain race are required for “authenticity”.
CommentsAds By Google
103 comments
+ Follow
Share
Post comment as...
Custom HTML Preview
To comment or reply, please login or create an account.
I think this is complete BS........... Employers should be allowed to hire anybody they want and need for their business. This is not about being "racist" but who wants to see an Indian working in a Korean Restaurant??? Who wants to see a Caucasian working in an Indian Restaurant??? Not only Restaurants - If it is a retail shop targeted at a certain race, you would want to have the same race work at the shop to make the customers feel more welcoming as their are people in Australia that struggle to speak English. Comments such as, if they cannot speak English they should leave the country, is far more racist than these acts of hiring certain race. What's the difference between advertising on their own community website for jobs, which Caucasians cannot view without knowing the language, and having them posted on the window of their shops? NOTHING... Discrimination / Racism occurs far more from the Caucasians but I don't see them being charged - think about all the poor Asians who was brought up in Australia, but because of their name, the resumes don't even get read properly (like myself). If regulatory bodies have time to investigate in these minor issues, they should invest more time into issues that actually matter.
I don't see a problem with it at all. Do they expect the person to employ someone that cannot communicate effectively with their customers? Do they expect them to get customers complaints and lose business??
Ridiculous! They know what is best for their business so let them get on with it. Hard enough to run a business these days without everyone sticking their noses in.
This comment has been deleted
This is a business where the employee must speak korean ,simple as that ,
And is is NOT "only if you’re Korean"" Stupid misleading headline .
Seems sensible to me. More jobs need to stipulate for English speakers only as well. Discrimination is the only way to get the best person for the job.
This comment has been deleted
There are many jobs where the ability to speak a particular language are necessary/important. In this case, given that many of the shop's customers speak Korean, how can someone who can't speak Korean fluently do the job well. It's a customer service job and you therefore have to be able to communicate with customers in a language they prefer to speak. Sure, if an employer advertises that they want Korean or Chinese or Italian or Malaysian (or whatever) they are breaching the law. However, I doubt that the employer in this case mean fully understood that. A friend of mine who is originally from New Zealand speaks fluent Korean - she was an interpreter and tour guide for Korean tourists travelling in Australia for several years. I suspect that if she turned up for an interview, introduced herself in Korean and engaged the owner in a conversation in Korean she would get a fair hearing.
it doesnt offend me . if the job requires a Korean or someone that speaks it …. go for it. As long as when i want to employ someone who requires a special skill i dont get any bleeding hearts complaining that i am discriminating.
its just common sense.
This comment has been deleted
Talk about overreacting, stop picking on the shop. Why didn't you go in to the shop and explain to them that they should change the sign to say, Korean speaking people wanted rather than attacking them when they most likley had no idea they were doing anything wrong.
This comment has been deleted
Hi, I am the owner of
Alice’s Diary.
I would like to take the opportunity to the accusations made in this article.
First and foremost, I would like to state that my English is quite poor, and whilst I make every effort to improve my language skills, English is my third language, after Chinese and Korean. Whilst I endeavor to improve my English, it is still not easy for me.
The sign stating “Korean staff wanted” was poorly worded and it was not my intent to imply that only Koreans seeking employment would be considered. Due to the nature of my business and the customers I cater towards, being able to speak Korean is extremely beneficial. At this point in time, the members of my staff are lacking in this aspect which is why I am seeking Korean speaking employees.
I understand that despite Australia being a multicultural society, English is the primary language and a certain fluency in the language is something I look for when interviewing potential employees. I would like to reiterate that my sign was a result of my poor English leading to misinterpretation.
Thank you for your understanding.
(This response was edited by a fluent English speaker prior to posting, but retains the original context of the initial draft written by the owner of Alice’s Diary)
What if the reporter was offered the job, would she have taken the job or just wasted the shops time.
Asians prefer to employ their own. A local well-known fast food franchise was owned by an Aussie and employed a diverse mix of people that represented multicultural Sydney. It was then sold to an Indian, and after a few months every single worker is now conveniently of Indian heritage. Most businesses are smart enough not to advertise for one particular culture though, instead they can tell from one's CV where they're originally from, and only call them in for an interview. Welcome to multicultural Australia.
This is pretty common in Sydney. Next time they will just write a sign in Korean- problem solved.
This comment has been deleted
This comment has been deleted
I am disgusted with the Telegraph and their slant on this story as a 68 year old Australian of First Fleeters descent I actually find this story a bit off. This is the same as advertising for someone and requesting that they speak English,no different. Of course they would need someone who speaks the language (most of their customers are Korean) and at least they are being up front about it. We have too many people doing jobs involving customers who cannot speak our (English ) language and indeed it used to be a stipulation that you did learn English (my Chinese wife was given 500 hours at school) and it still should be like that today.
@Graeme I don't think you get that they didn't ask for some one who "speaks" Korean they asked for someone who "is" Korean. There is a big difference, a Caucasian person can speak Korean but can't be Korean. Maybe if they are coming to an English speaking country they should try speaking English, we would have to learn their lingo if we go there, why should it be different here. Don't you think we are already being very tolerant?
This comment has been deleted
I have seen adverts for are for indigenous applicants, why then can't there be a job advert for Koreans/other applicants
This comment has been deleted
I didn't think they are discriminating if where the number of persons employed by the employer,
disregarding any persons employed within the employer’s private household, does not exceed 5.
I'd be interested to see how many white Aussies - there, I said, noone else will here - would have wanted to work at that place anyway; interested to see if anyone of a caucasian background would have bothered to walk in and ask them for a job, had the journo not gone in as a sting.
This comment has been deleted
This comment has been deleted
This comment has been deleted
This comment has been deleted
This comment has been deleted
The only real test of their true intention would have been to have a caucasion applicant who actually spoke Korean apply for the job. If they got turned down, then it IS discrimination.
This comment has been deleted
@Sandy-Lee
Not necessarily. Just because someone speaks Korean, doesn't mean they can do the job. It's not the only criterion.
@Tom @Sandy-Lee
Missing the point. My intention was, if you have two identically qualified applicants who both have a high level of linguistic ability, as required for the job, stating that they will employ the Korean over the caucasion based on their nationality, and not their ABILITY, is definitely racist.
Australians are being discriminated against every single day, we have no rights and the government is to blame. The government no longer protect there own people, It will be a lot worse in the next few years.
Where are all the grubby lefties now that were ranting when the coffee shop would not give a job to a native from some where other than Australia ..O! O! Sorry I forgot Discrimination is only designed to work against Australians and mainly against Anglo Celtic ones at that.
This kinda stuff is happening all over Sydney....Go into 7 eleven and I bet there is an Indian behind the counter.The truth is white Australians are being discriminated against constantly in this country but nothing is said.Its done deliberately.
@David
Because you want to work the night shift at 7-11 David??? Yeah, didn't think so.
@David.. Im sure you wont do overnight shifts at 7-11 for a slave wage of about 13-15 per hour. Indians will.
@David
this is not about just Australian my dear, this is in regards of hiring someone from a specific race to work there , it affects everyone, so don't turn this into us against them, this not happen to anyone, period.
@David
Based on conversations I have had with staff at various 7-11s, the problem seems to be below award wages. That is, immigrants more often agree to work for them & in many cases, do not even realise that awards exist. If the government did its job & enforced minimum wages, I believe we would see a wider variety of ethnic extractions behind the counter.
It makes sense if their clients speak korean it would be better for their business. More appropriate wording on the sign is preferable. They have probably saved all the english speaking applicants some time. They would never get the job anyway. Generally with discrimination you can have your own criteria and you just dont shortlist the ones that dont meet your criteria.seen it happen before.
But lets face it - were in Australia. Lets at least make an effort and learn the Australian language totally disrespectful and particularly when its a language you dont understand spoken in front of you.
You're conveniently forgetting that the only people who speak Korean are Koreans - it's not an international language like English- so the effect of such a policy is racially excluding non- Koreans.
@Carissa
Why would you go & say something silly like that? I have a friend who speaks korean fluently & makes a living teaching english to koreans. He is white & was born in New Zealand. Didn't you say earlier that you spoke a chinese language? By your logic, it is impossible that you could not be chinese right?
This comment has been deleted
@Caroline Yes, it's a badly written sign. Should have said 'Korean Speaking Staff Wanted'. Unfortunately, now some people have made it into a race issue!
Front page news, I think they are trying to promote DailyTelegraph staff are not Korean.
Are Koreans the only "race" who are able to converse in that language ? I think not. Therefore, how can the requirement to speak any language be "racist". If they said "Koreans only" it would be another matter. Typical beat up of a story based on the scourge or our era (aka political correctness)
@ian
So the sign on the door advertising for staff stating 'Korean Staff wanted' DOESN'T specify a race? I think you are to P.C. if you refuse to recognize what is in front of you!
@ian
well can't you read the sign. it does says Koreans wanted..... not korean language....
Show More Comments
Most Viewed
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Shot man had threatened to harm his father
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Choc gone, Mateo and Mason in, new CEO
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Starved boy fed through door
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Michelle’s dad faces court on assault charge
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'That’s Mau-boy, Jess shows the world
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Halloween killjoys spoil the fun like Scrooge
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Mum’s right to end daughter’s life
- counter(1.65326e+171), '.'Garvey slams Lisa revealing texts
Police nab con man Peter Foster after year on run
EXCLUSIVE: NOTORIOUS con man Peter Foster has been arrested near Byron Bay after a year on the run.
Penrith mosque will ‘change fabric of life’
PENRITH is set to get its first Islamic mosque, despite one critic’s claims it will attract crime and change the area’s fabric of life ‘irreversibly’.
25 tourists rushed to hospital after falling ill on bus
TWENTY FIVE tourists were rushed to hospital and remain in isolation after they fell severely ill on a bus in Sydney’s southwest this afternoon.
Guilty over shooting of Maha Hamze
A MAN has been found guilty of shooting the aunt of Supermax inmate Bassam Hamzy who was shot in the legs as she stood at the front door of her Auburn home last year.
Lawyer: I was wrong to fight sex abuse victims
A GOVERNMENT lawyer who used every technical defence available to fight a case by victims of shocking sexual abuse in a children’s home has admitted that he had been wrong.
Home Loan 4.56% p.a.
http://a.mozo.com.au/record_widget_gts?product_id=1026&product_type=HomeLoan&provider_id=1004&path=/widgets/dailytelegraph/dt-news&originaldc=widgets on dailytelegraph&partial=widget-layout-110&position=1&dctag=dailytelegraph&the_url=https://www.loans.com.au/lpn/6/Award-winning-home-loan-mz
loans.com.au Dream Home Loan Variable (Blackboard Special)
loans.com.au
- Borrow up to 90% of the property value
- Full featured loan
comparison rate
4.56%
Go to site
Go to siteFrom around the site
Catherine McNeil locks lips with new girlfriend
MODEL Catherine McNeil must be well and truly over her ex-fiancee Miles Lagford, having been photographed hooking up with her rumoured girlfriend just four months on.
Meet Packer and DiCaprio’s blonde bombshell
THE young woman pictured getting into a black car with James Packer and Leonardo DiCaprio has been revealed as 22-year-old Bryana Holly.
Katie Price to join The Morning Show
BRITISH bombshell Katie Price is set to join The Morning Show as a regular UK contributor.
Lauryn Eagle shows male fighters the ropes
Model Lauryn Eagle has pulled on the gloves and entered the ring with eight amateur boxers for Foxtel’s gritty new reality show.
Trim Mel’s ‘double chin’ milestone
HER battle with depression after the infamous royal radio hoax caused her weight to balloon. But nearly two years on, Mel Greig has turned her life around.
Shot man had threatened to harm his father
NEIGHBOURS have recounted the moments after Andrew Betteridge was shot by police in Sydney’s south west overnight. He allegedly advanced on police with a baseball bat.
How to fake it till you make it
CONFIDENCE is the key to becoming successful at pretty much anything in life. The problem is, many of us don’t have it. Here’s how to pretend until you do.
Melbourne could lose A-League grand final
EXCLUSIVE: FFA and AFL are in dispute over bookings of the MCG and Etihad which could prevent a Melbourne A-League grand final.
Crabb sets her sights on Boris
ANNABEL Crabb, who is hosting her fourth series of Kitchen Cabinet on ABC, wants to interview political heavyweights overseas.
Mata’utia to make Kangaroos history
NEWCASTLE whiz kid Sione Mata’utia is set to become the youngest ever Australian debutant after being named to play England. All Four Nations teams here.
The crazy new Melbourne Cup fashion trends
THERE are some new fashion trends emerging in the lead-up to this year’s Melbourne Cup. Here’s what the stylish among us will be wearing to impress other racegoers.
From Around the Network
Get the insights from Eureka Report, an expert team with a proven track record
DAILY DEALS
Shot man had threatened to harm his father
NEIGHBOURS have recounted the moments after Andrew Betteridge was shot by police in Sydney’s south west overnight. He allegedly advanced on police with a baseball bat.
Lawyer: I was wrong to fight sex abuse victims
A GOVERNMENT lawyer who used every technical defence available to fight a case by victims of shocking sexual abuse in a children’s home has admitted that he had been wrong.
The inside story of a text ‘coward’
BREEANA Robinson just wanted her man’s love. Instead, she copped endless vicious texts from him. Now she is dead.
Transfer centre: 2015 player movement
UPDATED: Feleti Mateo to the Sea Eagles. Brett Morris to the Bulldogs. Plus much more in our updated Transfer Centre.
‘Sneaky new tax on motorists’
THE Abbott government has increased the fuel excise in a bid to raise $2.2 billion over the next four years — and you will pay for it every time you fill up.
Phipps denies Wallabies have sexist culture
NICK Phipps has passionately denied a culture of misogyny exists in the Wallabies as the fallout from the Kurtley Beale text message scandal continues.
Mata’utia to make Kangaroos history
NEWCASTLE whiz kid Sione Mata’utia is set to become the youngest ever Australian debutant after being named to play England. All Four Nations teams here.
This is how NOT to run a fake play
THE New York Jets are having a bad year. This attempted kick return fake is so horrible, the commentators openly laughed. WATCH HERE
Gai’s Melbourne Cup defence in tatters
EXCLUSIVE: GAI Waterhouse will not defend her Melbourne Cup crown after withdrawing one-time favourite The Offer from next Tuesday’s big race.
Smith ready for promotion to No.3
MAN with a plan Steve Smith is spoiling to attack Pakistan’s mystery spinners in the pivotal No.3 slot as Australia scrambles for a final Test fix.
Dragons sign Rose on a one-year deal
THE ST GEORGE Illawarra Dragons have signed NRL journeyman and George Rose on a one-year deal for season 2015.
Ricciardo hails US ‘best of new breed F1 races’
DANIEL RICCIARDO has nothing but praise for the US Grand Prix a race he describes as “the best of the new breed of circuits”.
How to fake it till you make it
CONFIDENCE is the key to becoming successful at pretty much anything in life. The problem is, many of us don’t have it. Here’s how to pretend until you do.
Coca-Cola Amatil to axe 57 jobs
FIFTY-SEVEN jobs will be lost when beverages supplier Coca-Cola Amatil closes its production facility at Bayswater in Melbourne.
Petrol prices are about to rise
PREPARE to be hit at the pump. In its eagerness to raise money, the government has found a way to jack up your petrol prices.
Is this proof Gen Y is better than everyone?
GENERATION Y cops a lot of criticism, but the youngsters among us aren’t without any redeeming qualities. This one might surprise you.
Finance news you need to know today
NIGERIA is taking Coca-Cola to court over a Consumer Protection Order relating to two half-empty cans of Sprite.
Australian market set to open lower
AUSTRALIAN shares look set to open lower after a flat performance on Wall Street and sharp falls on European markets.
Lovely Linda happy to grow old naturally
THE former supermodel, in Sydney to film Australia’s Next Top Model (her first reality show) reveals that she’s quite happy to sport wrinkles as she approaches the big FIVE-O.
Lauryn Eagle shows male fighters the ropes
Model Lauryn Eagle has pulled on the gloves and entered the ring with eight amateur boxers for Foxtel’s gritty new reality show.
Didn’t Megan Gale just have a baby?
DIDN’T she just have a baby? That was the question Megan Gale’s followers were asking after she uploaded an image of her impossible toned body yesterday.
Catherine McNeil locks lips with new girlfriend
MODEL Catherine McNeil must be well and truly over her ex-fiancee Miles Lagford, having been photographed hooking up with her rumoured girlfriend just four months on.
Cate’s latest transformation
AUSSIE Oscar winner Cate Blanchett is known for fully immersing herself in character and her latest film is no different.
We’re a big, happy family on DWTS
RICKI-LEE Coulter Coulter says despite Mark Holden’s hijinks the Dancing With The Stars cast are one big happy family.
Gemma Ward's life advice for models and young women
The model speaks to Vogue
whilst shooting the latest campaign for Country Road.
7 simple ways to cut your bowel cancer risk
Bowel cancer is one of Australia's biggest killers, but there are ways you can significantly reduce your risk of the disease. By Brian Johnston.
Recipe of the day: coconut poached chicken and jasmine rice salad
This delicious coconut poached chicken and jasmine rice salad is healthy and easy to make.
Which runway trend are you for Halloween?
Vogue’s round up of the spring/summer ’15 trends that will inspire your Halloween costume. By Petta Chua.
12 foods that will help to prevent diabetes
Incorporate these 12 foods into your diet to reduce your diabetes risk.
Recipe of the day: green risotto with prawns and pea pesto
This creamy green risotto with pea and prawn pesto is sure to become a fast favourite.
Jerry Seib: The States That Will Tip the Election
As the election reaches its final week, Jerry Seib points out the state races that will make or break each partys ambitions for Senate control. Photo: AP
1:39
Rosie Batty is Vic Australian of the Year
Rosie Batty has been named 2015 Victorian Australian of the Year for work as a domestic violence campaigner.
2:00
Defence conduct final G20 preparations
Police, emergency services, and Defence are going through final preparations for the Brisbane G20 summit.
1:02
- Follow Us
- A NOTE ABOUT RELEVANT ADVERTISING: We collect information about the content (including ads) you use across this site and use it to make both advertising and content more relevant to you on our network and other sites. This is also known as Online Behavioural Advertising. You can find out more about our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out here .
- Privacy Policy
- Relevant Ads Opt-out
- Cookie Policy
- About Us
- Digital Print Edition
- Contact Us
- Sponsorship
- Letter to the Editor
- For the Record
- Place an Ad
- Advertise with us
- Photo Sales
- Archives
- Tributes
- Job Opportunities
- Journalism Program
- Help
- Accessibility
- Site Map
- Code of Conduct
- Terms of Use
- Subscription Terms
- Group Subscription Terms
- News Ltd 2014 Copyright
Welcome to
Log in
Log In
Using your favourite social network
Using your News Account
- Forgot your password?
- Don't have an account? Become a member here
Jimmy
Annette
Nicholas
Craig
Frank
Dirty
Tom
Jason
Brett
David