My favorites | Sign in
Project Home Downloads Wiki Issues Code Search
New issue   Search
for
  Advanced search   Search tips   Subscriptions
Issue 411335: Refresh button missing from Chrome Address Bar on Android
228 people starred this issue.
Comments by non-members will not trigger notification emails to users who starred this issue.
Back to list
Status:  Untriaged
Owner:  ----
Cc:  mwh...@chromium.org, kerz@chromium.org

Restricted
  • Only users with Commit permission may comment.


Sign in to add a comment
 
Reported by morax...@gmail.com, Sep 5, 2014
Steps to reproduce the problem:
1. Start Chrome
2. Refresh button is not there
3. 

What is the expected behavior?
The refresh/stop button should be to the immediate right of the address bar.

What went wrong?
The button is no longer there, and there is no setting change to put it back.

Did this work before? Yes The previous version installed.

Chrome version: 37  Channel: n/a
OS Version: 
Flash Version: Shockwave Flash 14.0 r0

According to one respondent on the help boards this is a new feature.  It is not, it is a design flaw in the UI and should be fixed immediately.
Sep 5, 2014
#2 BennettE...@gmail.com
This also is happening on my wife's phone
Sep 5, 2014
#3 morax...@gmail.com
If this problem is occurring for your phone as well, comment here *and* open up a new issue with Chrome. 
Sep 5, 2014
#4 BennettE...@gmail.com
Looks like the button was moved.  I hit the 3 dot settings button and the refresh is right there. 
Sep 5, 2014
#5 morax...@gmail.com
The button was moved from the address bar to the menu.  Instead of one touch to refresh, it's now two touches.  Ditto for two touches to stop a page from loading.  Very inconvenient.
Sep 5, 2014
#6 evita.em...@gmail.com
I have this issue as well. I want the refresh button back on the address bar! 
Sep 5, 2014
#7 brilj...@gmail.com
Extremely incontinent that the refresh button was moved. I am serving to another browser if this is not resolved soon. Very inconvenient.

Sep 5, 2014
#8 morax...@gmail.com
I would suggest that if you find this to be an issue that you not only comment here but open up your own issue as well. If there are more issues active, they will have to address this bug.
Sep 5, 2014
#9 dnynumbe...@gmail.com
This design change is so incomprehensibly idiotic. Why on earth did someone think this was a good idea?
Sep 5, 2014
#10 morax...@gmail.com
Not surprised no one from Google has responded here... annoying, but not surprising.
Sep 5, 2014
#11 Barbecue...@gmail.com
Ugh. Just put the damn refresh button back.
Sep 5, 2014
#12 frankyca...@gmail.com
It's now a 2 - step process.  Press the menu button and click the refresh symbol on the top left.




Screenshot_2014-09-05-21-44-14.png
183 KB   View   Download
Sep 5, 2014
#13 morax...@gmail.com
That's the bug. It used to be a one step process. Adding no functionality and making the product harder to use is a BUG!
Sep 6, 2014
#14 huijb...@gmail.com
My bug was closed wont fix almost immediately :( this change is zo stupid

https://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=411313
Sep 6, 2014
#15 vangelis...@gmail.com
My decision to buy a $500 Android device was based in part on the fact that I found the web browser convenient, in the form it was presented to me in the store. Google has no right to deliberately degrade my valuable property.
This new bug is especially painful if the requested site is hard to reach. Usually, I'd hit 'reload' several times until the page is loaded properly. With the reload button buried in the menu, it now takes forever to load such pages.
Sep 6, 2014
#16 bjopling...@googlemail.com
+1

Irritating on several counts - updating my phone without asking me and then removing functionality I found useful.

Bring the refresh button back now, please - it strikes me as arrogant to act in this way.
Sep 6, 2014
#17 bjopling...@googlemail.com
...it just seems idiotic. What are they hoping to achieve? A 'cleaner' look? The address bar is hidden from sight after loading the page anyway, it's just adding hassle and providing no benefit.

Argh.
Sep 6, 2014
#18 markf...@googlemail.com
Move the refresh button back!!! 

Sep 6, 2014
#19 Josephx...@gmail.com
Very dumb to move and hide the refresh button. if this is not resolved soon ill migrate to another browser that is smart enough to keep the refresh button for easy user access.
Sep 6, 2014
#20 wintyfr...@gmail.com
Definitely a terrible ui decision.
Sep 6, 2014
#21 Nicole.T...@gmail.com
This is some bull. It really needs to be changed back....
Sep 6, 2014
#22 rydub...@gmail.com
Noticed this last night and am not happy about it.  Just pretty much ruined the browser with this "feature" 
Sep 6, 2014
#24 randerso...@googlemail.com
Bring it back please! Opening the menu each time is annoying.
Sep 6, 2014
#25 p...@philhemmis.com
Just noticed this as well after updating to v37, how irritating. Please, pretty please, return the reload+stop icons in the address box!
Sep 6, 2014
#26 JoostHel...@gmail.com
Wrong change,  please change back in order to serve existing customers. 
Sep 6, 2014
#27 salee...@gmail.com
Google, fix this.
Sep 6, 2014
#28 odol...@gmail.com
Please star this issue. That's the only way Google action bugs - based on the number of "star" ratings they have. 
Top left of this discussion is a white star. Click to activate
Sep 6, 2014
#29 huijb...@gmail.com
I wanted to say that but then I realized only the people who had already starred this issue would be notified :(
Sep 6, 2014
#30 artelof...@gmail.com
Change the windows box and put the reload/stop button, the windows box is duplicated, you can get the same result sliding the address bar...
Sep 6, 2014
#32 mikep...@gmail.com
Very inconvenient. I wish Google wouldn't try so hard to minimalise and simplify every GUI, it's not a crime to have a few necessary buttons visible at all times!!
Sep 6, 2014
#33 adelsc...@gmail.com
I want it back !
Sep 6, 2014
#34 jorgen.l...@gmail.com
Why did they move the refresh button? Such an idiotic desicion from Google.
Sep 6, 2014
#35 fast...@gmail.com
Come on google wtf is this about? Lets make life more difficult..
Sep 6, 2014
#36 adjes...@gmail.com
Google, FIX THIS or I'm going to install another browser. 
Sep 6, 2014
#37 vke...@gmail.com
This issue must be fixed immediately...
Its definitely a bug or the developers must have gone crazy to make people's life more difficult.
Sep 6, 2014
#38 skydra...@gmail.com
The forward and favorite buttons have seldom use, so I absolutely understand their placement in a context menu.

The refresh button is necessary, and often used; please place it on the address bar, as hiding it is not a feature. It's a bug.
Sep 6, 2014
#39 dogla...@gmail.com
Yeah this is stupid.  Put the refresh button back you silly sausages.
Sep 6, 2014
#40 tharr...@gmail.com
Please put refresh back! 
Sep 6, 2014
#41 cragn...@gmail.com
Please fire the person(s) who thought Removing this was a good idea! 

Sep 6, 2014
#42 rjone...@att.net
Just remove update until a fix comes
Sep 6, 2014
#44 keav...@gmail.com
Entirely remove the tab button so the URL fills the entire bar, then put a small reload button back like before. The reload button is extremely useful, but the tab button is entirely useless because it's to the same effect as swiping down on the bar.
Sep 6, 2014
#45 racerXon...@gmail.com
Refresh button? The BACK button is totally gone! I used it all the time/
Sep 6, 2014
#46 seckaro...@gmail.com
Also would like the refresh button back as it was...will prob have to try a diff browser now, because of that...
Sep 6, 2014
#47 kev.g...@gmail.com
Sometimes I really wonder what goes on in their minds to actually think that moving the stop/refresh button was a good idea. And to think that the idea was approved by their bosses too. 
Sep 6, 2014
#48 bhagatra...@gmail.com
The back button is very important. .. much more important than the refresh button. . Fit refreshing one can still click on menu and refresh. .. but now one can't go BACK at all ... Google. . Need the back button on chrome else a whole lot of people would stop using this browser
Rahul
Sep 7, 2014
#49 fuhxa...@gmail.com
Moving the refresh button was a bad, bad idea. I'd like to see it put back to its former location.
Sep 7, 2014
#50 odol...@gmail.com
Back button wasn't so important as you cab always use the back arrow at the bottom odd you're screen
Remember to star this page
Sep 7, 2014
#51 racerXon...@gmail.com
Always used the back button to go back pages or back to the initial search. Now when I first start chrome, I can't go back a page from where I'm at. Using the permanent icon on my phone will just close the browser. Wish I hadn't updated.

Sep 7, 2014
#52 mertdo...@hotmail.com
Take back refresh button please
Sep 7, 2014
#53 Shimon.B...@gmail.com
few month ago i left the beta version because of missing refresh and poor tab number display, now they merged the versions and there is no escape.
please fix it.
Sep 7, 2014
#54 grr...@gmail.com
No refresh button, and loads the speed dial page instead of bookmarks on startup. These are THE two reasons I wasn't using Firefox. FFS Google. 
Sep 7, 2014
#55 michaelr...@gmail.com
I don't have it either!
Sep 7, 2014
#56 koko.reu...@gmail.com
yes please bring it back, it's stupid to remove it because of "design" -_-
Sep 7, 2014
#57 James.We...@gmail.com
Change it back please
Sep 7, 2014
#58 carlos2...@gmail.com
My refresh button not showing up either.  I don't even have a menu button!  How do I refresh?!
Sep 7, 2014
#59 giedrius...@gmail.com
I hwve this problem as well.
I have seen this few weeks earlier in some designs and was worrying for it not to make to final version. There is nothing better to do than ruin perfectly working UX in favor of cleaner UI? Seems like hipsters are taking the world...
Sep 7, 2014
#60 sssmacar...@gmail.com
This is the most annoying place fir the reload button please move it back
Sep 7, 2014
#61 dshule...@gmail.com
This is one of those times I wish I could read minds. 

"Hey guys, let's make the refresh button hidden and two clicks away. I'm sure out customers would love that!"

How are high paid executives who make these decisions SO STUPID?! 

YOU DON'T HAVE TO CONSTANTLY MAKE UNNECCESSARY CHANGES TO VALIDATE YOUR JOB. 
Sep 7, 2014
#62 mbel...@gmail.com
Give me back my refresh button! 
Sep 7, 2014
#63 jcalabri...@gmail.com
Knucklehead move. 
Sep 7, 2014
#64 williamw...@gmail.com
Adding my voice to the bring back the one touch refresh/stop loading button party. Ill be using firefox till it gets fixed. 
Sep 7, 2014
#65 svh01...@gmail.com
Bring back the refresh button!
Sep 7, 2014
#66 david.ca...@gmail.com
Whose idea was this. Morons.
Sep 7, 2014
#67 BWE...@gmail.com
I seriously never complain on google's forums, but this can't be intentional.  I don't care what goal for simplistic designs you have in mind google, removing essential ui functions isn't the way.  Good lord, what a stupid decision.  
Sep 7, 2014
#68 AndyJ...@gmail.com
With the generally weak internet connections you get with a mobile phone, pages often fail to load properly or up date..  I use the refresh button constantly..  I definitely want it back.. 
Sep 7, 2014
#69 rtier...@gmail.com
Defintely a step back for usability and convenience. 
Sep 7, 2014
#70 FLOYD...@gmail.com
I too lost ability to refresh. And it can't be done on the menu either. Man this sucks. Tried Firefox didn't see a way to refresh it either!
Sep 7, 2014
#71 vivekkum...@gmail.com
I want refresh button back too! That's annoying seriously :/
Sep 7, 2014
#72 Alex.wil...@gmail.com
The back button on my phone quit working after I repaired the glass and I started using the back button in the browser. Then you take it away?  Not cool, Google.
Sep 8, 2014
#73 Strategi...@gmail.com
Why would you move the refresh icon? Poor design.
Sep 8, 2014
#74 mfxp...@gmail.com
Put the refresh icon back where it was Google !!!!!!!
Sep 8, 2014
#75 Jinxyk...@gmail.com
Ditto for this, and while you are at it on the desktop version take away the stupid search bar from the new tabs page. We have a bloody omni bar to search for shit, I do not need a redundant search bar. Just leave people with choice.
Sep 8, 2014
#78 jmcs...@gmail.com
Switching to cmbrowser until it's restored.
Sep 8, 2014
#79 g.m.hage...@gmail.com
I Prefer the old functionality as well. My experience when commuting is very poor now, pages just keep hanging and the reload i used to use is inconvenient to reach
Sep 8, 2014
#80 m.p.mars...@gmail.com
I assume they are trying to make the UI 'cleaner', but the refresh button in the search/URL bar was very useful. Please bring it back!
Sep 8, 2014
#81 barryand...@gmail.com
No refresh button - fail.
Sep 8, 2014
#82 melody...@chromium.org
 Issue 411577  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 8, 2014
#83 melody...@chromium.org
+Matt and Kerz

Feedback is also being reported through ConOps channels on this UI change. 
Cc: mwh...@chromium.org kerz@chromium.org
Labels: Hotlist-ConOps M-37 Cr-UI
Sep 8, 2014
#84 mmonc...@gmail.com
please bring it back -- ugh. I miss the stop button most of all because I can nip some sites before the aware opens up.  What was wrong with the old design?  Why was it changed?
Sep 8, 2014
#85 mmonc...@gmail.com
please bring it back -- ugh. I miss the stop button most of all because I can nip some sites before the aware opens up.  What was wrong with the old design?  Why was it changed?
Sep 8, 2014
#86 krazyrab...@gmail.com
Fix this issue NOW. What a stupid decision that does not add a simplification but takes one away. Will go to Dolphin if refresh not restored.

Sep 8, 2014
#87 krbb...@gmail.com
I now have to use 2 clicks to refresh a page? No no no, this will not fly.  Apparently I use refresh a lot, never noticed til it was gone! This is silly,  please bring it back google... Also do away with the silly new Google search/address bar box in the middle of a new tab... this too is silly, and no good.
Sep 8, 2014
#88 morax...@gmail.com
Melody wrote:  

 #82 melody...@chromium.org

  Issue 411577   has been merged into this issue.


Why?  If you're getting more and more issues on this, instead of spending time merging them, fix the damn bug already!
Sep 8, 2014
#89 huijb...@gmail.com
@ #88 morax...@gmail.com
Probably not everyone @google, eg. Melody, thought this change to be a good idea either
Sep 8, 2014
#90 ejhus...@gmail.com
This is terrible design.  Why would you double the amount of clicks needed for Refresh or Stop?  Some people use these buttons frequently.
Sep 8, 2014
#91 richgo...@gmail.com
I used Google because it came with my phone going back to Opera were it's much faster and customisable your loss
Sep 8, 2014
#92 boulde...@gmail.com
I agree with everyone that it was idiotic to remove the refresh button. I use it a lot and now have to go through an extra step just to refresh the page. That makes about as much sense as wiping before you poop. 
Sep 8, 2014
#93 edodonn...@gmail.com
Have downgraded to version 36 till the refresh button comes back, and new tab can display favorites.

My guess on why these unfortunate changes were made?  Drive more google searches through chrome, at all costs.  The refresh button makes it look like a bar where you type an address, instead of a place you just fire a search.  The same goal would explain the growth in height of the bar, and the dumb New Tab page.  They're trying to force search queries over standard address entry.
Sep 8, 2014
#94 jolson.s...@gmail.com
Guess I'm using a different easier to use browser that isn't so embedded with my Google account.   It was a bad idea for Internet Explorer and it's a bad idea for chrome. 
Sep 8, 2014
#95 thestig@chromium.org
There's sufficient feedback regarding this issue. "Me too" comments don't add anything useful at this point. You can vote on this bug by starring it near the top left corner.
Status: Untriaged
Labels: Restrict-AddIssueComment-Commit
Sep 8, 2014
#96 amin...@google.com
Moving all non essential bugs to the next Milestone.
Labels: -M-37 MovedFrom-37 M-38
Sep 9, 2014
#97 smok...@chromium.org
 Issue 411880  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 9, 2014
#98 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 412164  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 9, 2014
#99 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 411694  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 9, 2014
#100 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 411680  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 9, 2014
#101 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 411650  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 9, 2014
#102 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 411603  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 9 (6 days ago)
#103 matthewy...@chromium.org
This issue has already been moved once and is lower than Priority 1,therefore removing mstone.
Labels: -M-38 MovedFrom-38
Sep 9 (6 days ago)
#104 danakj@chromium.org
Is there some data that shows this as an improvement? Can someone from the android UI team own this?
Sep 9 (6 days ago)
#105 thestig@chromium.org
(Posting on moraxian's behalf) I wonder why anyone would consider a bug in the product to be an improvement. The lack of a refresh button on the address bar is a bug. To me it looks like the UI developers forgot it and then jammed it onto the drop down menu when they realized what they did.  I can't believe intelligent UI developers would eliminate the refresh/stop button from the main browser window intentionally.
Sep 11 (4 days ago)
#106 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 412533  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 11 (4 days ago)
#107 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 413177  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 11 (4 days ago)
#108 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 413243  has been merged into this issue.
Sep 11 (4 days ago)
#109 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 413275  has been merged into this issue.
Today (28 minutes ago)
#110 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 413594  has been merged into this issue.
Today (28 minutes ago)
#111 dhw@chromium.org
 Issue 413566  has been merged into this issue.
Sign in to add a comment

Powered by Google Project Hosting