Anders Behring Breivik, a Norwegian, killed 77 people in a bombing and a shooting rampage in Oslo and on Utoya Island, a summer camp for young political activists, on July 22, 2011.
Mr. Breivik, a right-wing extremist, admitted to the slayings in a court hearing shortly afterward, but denied criminal guilt, portraying the victims as “traitors” for embracing multiculturalism and Muslim immigration policies.
On Aug. 24, 2012, a Norwegian court sentenced Mr. Breivik to 21 years in prison after ruling that he had been sane at the time of the massacre. The sentence is the longest provided by Norwegian law; it can be extended if Mr. Breivik is later deemed to still be a menace to society.
His 10-week trial, which ended in June, centered on the question of his sanity. Defense lawyers argued that Mr. Breivik was sane when he bombed buildings in downtown Oslo, killing eight people, before killing 69 people at a summer youth camp run by the Labour Partyd, and should therefore be sentenced to prison. Prosecutors said that he was mentally ill, was not criminally responsible, and should be hospitalized instead.
Members of the defense team had evoked Mr. Breivik’s human rights in their conclusion that he should be held accountable for his crimes. Mr. Breivik has said that the killings were committed in self-defense to combat what he has called the “Islamic colonization” of Europe. He has argued that an insanity judgment would detract from his cause.
“The defendant has a radical political project,” said one of his lawyers. “To make his acts something pathological and sick deprives him of his right to take responsibility for his own actions.”
A judge said that the decision reached by the five-member panel hearing the case had been unanimous. Reading from a 90-page judgment, she refuted Mr. Breivik’s assertion that he acted as part of a network called the Knights Templar, saying there was no evidence to prove its existence. Mr. Breivik has said he was present when it was founded in London in 2002.
The bombing and shooting spree convulsed Norway, and the country’s police chief was forced to resign in August 2012 after an independent commission found that the police could have averted or at least disrupted Mr. Breivik’s plot.
Report Faults Police Response
The report by an independent commission also said the domestic intelligence service could have done more to track down Mr. Breivik while he conducted his shooting rampage, but stopped short of saying it could have stopped him.
While noting that the attacks “may be the most shocking and incomprehensible acts ever experienced in Norway,” the 500-page report said the bombing “could have been prevented” if already adopted security measures had been implemented more effectively.
Mr. Breivik was able to park a van with a fertilizer bomb just outside the high-rise government headquarters building in Oslo before he drove another car to the Labor Party’s youth camp on Utoya.
The 500-page report said that a car bomb “at the government complex and several coordinated attacks have been recurring scenarios in threat assessments as well as for safety analyses and exercise scenarios for many years.”
Plans to close off the street in front of the government building were approved in 2010, but work on constructing physical barriers had not been completed and no temporary obstacles had been set up. A parking ban in the area was not strictly enforced.
The police response to the shooting spree was slowed down by a series of blunders, including flaws in communication systems and the breakdown of an overloaded boat carrying a police anti-terror unit. Meanwhile, Norway’s only police helicopter was left unused, its crew on vacation.
Background
Mr. Breivik attended the elite high school where the country’s current king, Harald V, and his son once studied. Former classmates remembered him as quiet but intelligent, with a small rebellious streak: he was a prolific graffiti artist.
Former classmates and colleagues described him as unremarkable and easy to forget, qualities, perhaps inborn, that he cultivated — consciously, he would say — to mask his dedication to what he called his “martyrdom operation.”
Once a schoolboy who was fond of hip-hop and had a Muslim best friend, in his 20s he began to view the immigrants who flowed freely into Norway and elsewhere in Europe as enemies, and those who sought to accommodate them as traitors, worthy only of execution.
For years, Mr. Breivik participated in debates in Internet forums on the dangers of Islam and immigration. It is not clear at what point he decided that violence was the solution to the ills he believed were tearing European civilization asunder. Before the attacks he was careful never to telegraph his intentions.
Early in life, Mr. Breivik, far from being a radical, appeared to be on a track to join Norway’s political establishment. He grew up in Skoyen, a middle-class district of western Oslo. His father, a civil servant, and mother, a nurse, divorced when he was 1. Beyond that, his childhood seems to have been uneventful; Mr. Breivik said in his manifesto that it was happy.
Toward the end of high school, he joined the youth wing of the Progress Party, drawn to its anti-immigrant platform and market capitalist bent. But those who knew him from those days said that he failed to leave much of a mark.
He began to struggle with life, those who knew him said. He became estranged from his father, who moved to France. Then his sister, Elisabeth, on whom he seemed to rely in his father’s absence, moved to the United States and married an American.
It was a time when, according to his manifesto, his political views began to transmute. He began to perceive what he said was the hostility of Muslim youth. He latched on to reports of attacks against ethnic Norwegian men and rapes of ethnic Norwegian women by immigrant gangs.
Mr. Breivik wrote that the NATO bombing of Serbia in 1999 was a tipping point for him, describing the operation meant to halt a genocide as a betrayal of a fellow Christian people for the sake of Muslims.
He spent the next decade slowly working out his plan, though few people, it seems, had any inkling of it.
To earn money for the attacks, he wrote that he had started a company that earned him millions. Neighbors cast doubt on this claim, however, saying that they thought he had inherited some money from relatives.
As he went about gathering six tons of ammonium nitrate fertilizer and turning aspirin powder into pure acetylsalicylic acid for his bomb, he led an active life online, railing against Muslims and Marxists in debate forums.
The police say he rented a farm in eastern Norway, not far from the capital, and holed up there for several months to prepare his bomb.
Breivik’s Writings
A Facebook page and a Twitter account set up under his name days before the rampage suggest a conscious effort to construct a public persona and leave a legacy for others. Mr. Breivik cited philosophers like Machiavelli, Kant and John Stuart Mill. Although there did not appear to be calls for violence in his Internet postings, he hinted at his will to act in his lone Twitter post, paraphrasing Mill: “One person with a belief is equal to the force of 100,000 who have only interests.”
In a 1,500-page manifesto, posted on the Web hours before the attacks, Mr. Breivik recorded a day-by-day diary of months of planning for the attacks, and claimed to be part of a small group that intended to “seize political and military control of Western European countries and implement a cultural conservative political agenda.”
He predicted a conflagration that would kill or injure more than a million people, adding, “The time for dialogue is over. We gave peace a chance. The time for armed resistance has come.”
Mr. Breivik’s manifesto spells out plans for using anthrax as part of his war to defend Europe against what he called the rising threat of Muslim domination. But experts in biological weapons said the manifesto showed no evidence that he had actually obtained the lethal germ or could wield it as a weapon. They said the document — at least on the subject of germ attacks — evoked the air of an armchair theorist rather than someone poised to commit mass slaughter.
The manifesto was signed Andrew Berwick, an Anglicized version of his name. The manifesto, entitled “2083: A European Declaration of Independence,” equates liberalism and multiculturalism with “cultural Marxism,” which the document says is destroying European Christian civilization.
The document also describes a secret meeting in London in April 2002 to reconstitute the Knights Templar, a Crusader military order. It says the meeting was attended by nine representatives of eight European countries, evidently including Mr. Breivik, with an additional three members unable to attend, including a “European-American.”
A Well-Organized Attack
One thing is certain: the killings pointed to a meticulous and well-organized attack on Norway’s current and future political elite. Police said that after Mr. Breivik exploded a car bomb outside government offices in downtown Oslo, he then traveled to Utoya Island, a wooded retreat sponsored by Norway’s Liberal Party, located about 19 miles northwest of Oslo. He went to the camp, which is accessible only by boat, dressed as a police officer. Once there, he said he had come to check on the security of the young political campers. He then gathered them together and proceeded, coldly, to shoot them and then hunt down those who fled.
As soon as the shooting started, witnesses said, people panicked, running in all directions, tumbling down the island’s rocky hill in an attempt to reach the sea. Even after many made it into the water, Mr. Breivik calmly and methodically shot at those who were swimming.
He was equipped, the police said, with an automatic rifle and a handgun; when the police finally got to the island, about 40 minutes after the shooting started, Mr. Breivik surrendered when they called out to him, dropping his weapons. The police said that they had difficulty reaching the island, which delayed their response.
Norway’s prime minister, Jens Stoltenberg, had been scheduled to speak to the campers; a former leader of Labor’s youth wing, he had attended the camp every summer since 1974.
Fearful of Multiculturalism
To the consternation of many Norwegians, Mr. Breivik appears to have achieved at least one of his stated aims — a highly visible platform, with the eyes of the world upon him.
The authorities have described Mr. Breivik as a fundamentalist Christian, a gun-loving Norwegian obsessed with what he saw as the threat of multiculturalism and Muslim immigration to the cultural and patriotic values of his country.
Mr. Breivik’s lawyer, Geir Lippestad, has described him as a “very cold” person who lived in his own world, buttressed by drugs and the belief that he was a warrior doomed to die for a cause that others did not comprehend. He said that his client called the killings “atrocious,’' but “necessary.”
Depicted as a Loner
On the second day of the trial, Mr. Breivik described the deaths as “the most spectacular sophisticated political act in Europe since the Second World War” and said he would do it over again. He rejected an assessment by one psychiatrist that he suffered from a narcissistic personality disorder. “July 22 wasn’t about me. July 22 was a suicide attack. I wasn’t expecting to survive that day,” he said.
On the third and fourth days of the trial, prosecutors pressed Mr. Breivik on his extremist affiliations. He insisted that he belonged to a “cell” within an organization with members across Europe. He sweated and equivocated through skeptical prosecutors’ questioning about his trips to Liberia and London in 2002, during which he says he met a Serbian war criminal and was a founder of the organization the Knights Templar.
As prosecutors chipped away at the question of what happened on his travels, Mr. Breivik seemed to sense that they were seeking to portray him as a fantasist and a loner. But he refused to explain the trip, saying he did not want to expose other network members.
Prosecutors continued to depict Mr. Breivik as a friendless loser, rather than the founder of a shadowy terrorism group.
Contradictory Reports on Mental Health
Two court-ordered psychiatric reports had contradictory conclusions as to the question of Mr. Breivik’s sanity.
The first court-ordered assessment of his mental health, submitted in November 2011, found him to be psychotic and a paranoid schizophrenic. The authors of the report said Mr. Breivik suffered a psychotic meltdown in 2006 when he lost money in a failed share deal, moved back in with his mother in western Oslo and began playing World of Warcraft, an online role-playing game, for 16 hours a day.
The report said his mental condition left him “emotionally flattened” and led to the delusion that he was a member of a pan-European militant network that had invested in him the right to choose who should live and die.
Mr. Breivik maintains that the militant network really exists, a contention that prosecutors said is absurd. Police interviews and their own cross-examination, they said, reveal someone who has substituted a myth for an unsatisfactory life story.
A second court-ordered mental health assessment, delivered in April 2012, found that Mr. Breivik was sane at the time of the attacks.
During the trial, by turns defiant, impassive and tearful, Mr. Breivik proclaimed that he acted in self-defense, bore no criminal guilt and rejected the authority of the court. He had previously denied criminal responsibility on the ground that he was protecting Norway against Islamic immigration.
In remarkable evidence played to a packed and shocked courtroom, recordings of cellphone calls made by the gunman to the police suggested that he tried twice to give himself up and simply went on killing in the absence of officers to accept his surrender. In the period after the first call to his final shot being fired, prosecutors said, 41 people died. There has been much questioning of why the police took more than an hour to reach the island after the gunman launched the attack.
Anders Behring Breivik Chronology
-
Aug. 25, 2012
Norwegian extremist Anders Behring Breivik is sentenced to 21 years in prison, following his conviction for killing 77 people in 2011 in a horrific bombing and shooting attack; sentence is the maximum available under Norwegian law.MORE »
-
Aug. 17, 2012
Norway’s police chief Oeystein Maeland resigns, days after an independent commission found that the police could have prevented the far-right militant Anders Behring Breivik from killing 77 people in a bombing in Oslo and a massacre at a youth summer camp in 2011.MORE »
-
Aug. 14, 2012
Independent inquest into the mass killings in Norway in July 2011 by a fanatical anti-Muslim extremist sharply rebukes the country's police and intelligence services; says they could have averted or at least disrupted his plot to bomb downtown Oslo and finds the police failed in their duty to protect the camp where 69 people, most of them teenagers, were killed by Anders Behring Breivik.MORE »
-
Jun. 23, 2012
Trial of Anders Behring Breivik ends with defense lawyers insisting that he should be sentenced to prison and prosecutors arguing that he was mentally ill and thus not criminally responsible; experts say they are not aware of any previous case in Norwegian legal history in which prosecutors had called for an insanity verdict and defense lawyers had advocated conviction; if the court finds that Breivik was sane when he killed 77 people last year, he will face a maximum of 21 years in prison.MORE »
-
Jun. 22, 2012
Norwegian prosecutors ask a trial court in Oslo to order Anders Behring Breivik, who has admitted killing 77 people, confined for compulsory psychiatric treatment instead of sentencing him to prison.MORE »
ARTICLES ABOUT ANDERS BEHRING BREIVIK
What a Difference a Massacre Makes
On the anniversary of Anders Behring Breivik’s killing spree, Norway revisits a tamer kind of evil.
July 23, 2013, TuesdayLife in Prison Suite Doesn’t Agree With a Mass Killer
Anders Behring Breivik, who killed 77 people in Norway in 2011, complained about being strip-searched, isolated and being issued a pen that made his hand cramp.
November 10, 2012, SaturdayNorway Mass Killer Gets the Maximum: 21 Years
Anders Behring Breivik, who admitted to killing 77 people, many of them children, will live in a three-cell suite. The relative leniency of his sentence is no anomaly.
August 25, 2012, SaturdayBreivik Gets 21-Year Sentence in Norway for 77 Killings
Anders Behring Breivik, who admitted to killing 77 people, many of them children, will live in a three-cell suite. The relative leniency of his sentence is no anomaly.
August 24, 2012, FridayAt Breivik Trial, a Chance for Norway to Heal
The mass-murder trial shows how full acknowledgment of the truth of human suffering can help heal the victims, their families and a whole nation.
August 23, 2012, ThursdayNorway: Police Chief Steps Down After Critical Report
Oeystein Maeland has been criticized for failing to face up to police shortcomings regarding far-right militant Anders Behring Breivik, who killed 77 people last year in a bombing in Oslo and a massacre at a youth summer camp.
August 17, 2012, FridayNorway: Police Chief Steps Down After Critical Report
Oeystein Maeland has been criticized for failing to face up to police shortcomings regarding far-right militant Anders Behring Breivik, who killed 77 people last year in a bombing in Oslo and a massacre at a youth summer camp.
August 16, 2012, ThursdayIn Norway, Panel Lists Police Faults in Massacre
An independent inquest rebuked the police and intelligence services for a series of errors in the handling of last summer’s bombing and gun attacks by Anders Behring Breivik.
August 14, 2012, TuesdayNorway Panel on Massacre Finds Litany of Government Failures
An independent inquest rebuked the police and intelligence services for a series of errors in the handling of last summer’s bombing and gun attacks by Anders Behring Breivik.
August 13, 2012, MondayLearning From Norway’s Tragedy
Our response to extremist terror must be more openness and more democracy.
July 19, 2012, ThursdayAt Trial’s End, Lawyers Say Norway Killer Is Not Insane
The defense team for Anders Behring Breivik said he was sane when he killed 77 people in Norway’s worst peacetime atrocity, and should be sentenced to prison.
June 23, 2012, SaturdayDevil's Advocate: Breivik Lawyer Defends Rule of Law
Lawyers are accustomed to being called on to defend the indefensible, but the man who represented Anders Breivik, the Norwegian mass killer, said it was a task that threatened to take his soul.
June 22, 2012, FridayProsecutors in Norway Seek Hospital for Gunman
Anders Behring Breivik has admitted killing 77 people, most of them teenagers from the Labour Party, in twin attacks on July 22, 2011.
June 22, 2012, FridayTrial of Oslo Killer Ends, With Lawyers Saying He Is Sane
The defense team for Anders Behring Breivik said he was sane when he killed 77 people in Norway’s worst peacetime atrocity, and should be sentenced to prison.
June 23, 2012, SaturdayAnders Breivik Prosecutors Seek Psychiatric Confinement
Anders Behring Breivik has admitted killing 77 people, most of them teenagers from the Labour Party, in twin attacks on July 22, 2011.
June 22, 2012, FridaySEARCH 95 ARTICLES ABOUT ANDERS BEHRING BREIVIK:
Multimedia
Will the Norway Massacre Deflate Europe's Right Wing?
The killings could weaken nationalist fervor in Europe, as the Oklahoma City bombing cooled off militias in the U.S. in the late 1990s.
Multimedia
Loss and Healing in Norway
Scenes of grief and consolation played out in Norway as the nation attempted to recover from the scars of the massacre on July 22.
A Day of Mourning in Oslo
Mourners gathered on Monday in Oslo to pay tribute to the victims of Saturday’s bombing in Oslo and shooting on Utoya Island.
Aftermath of Norway Violence
As Norwegians began to cope with the killings in Oslo and on an island to the northwest, survivors met with their families and the search for bodies continued.
MOST POPULAR
- Well: Making the Case for Eating Fruit
- State of the Art: Chromecast, Simply and Cheaply, Flings Web Video to TVs
- Well: How Exercise Changes Fat and Muscle Cells
- 36 Hours in Portsmouth, N.H.
- Well: The Ticktock of the Death Clock
- Op-Ed Columnist: Politics of a Screeching Halt
- Crowds Return to Las Vegas, but Gamble Less
- Rome Journal: Road Through Roman History Creates Colossal Headache
- The Pragmatist: Banning Guests That Bite or Buzz
- House Proud: Life on the Farm: E-I-E-I ...Oh?
Rss Feeds On Anders Behring Breivik
Subscribe to an RSS feed on this topic. What is RSS?