.

Osaka mayor Toru Hashimoto: Sex slaves in World War Two were necessary to 'maintain discipline' for Japanese military

The conservative politician also told reporters there was no clear evidence that the Japanese military coerced women to become what are euphemistically called 'comfort women'

Tuesday 14 May 2013
Send
Send
Recommend
Recommend
765764
This page has been shared 184 times. View these Tweets.
42
Your friend's email address
Your email address
Note: We do not store your email address(es) but your IP address will be logged to prevent abuse of this feature. Please read our Legal Terms & Policies
A A A
1 / 1
Toru Hashimoto old reporters there was no clear evidence that the Japanese military coerced women to become what are euphemistically called 'comfort women'
AFP/Getty Images
Ads by Google

The Japanese military's forced prostitution of Asian women before and during the Second Word War was necessary to “maintain discipline” in the ranks and provide rest for soldiers who risked their lives in battle, an outspoken politician has said.
Asian countries that bore the brunt of Japan's wartime aggression have long complained that Japan has failed to fully atone for wartime atrocities.
Speaking yesterday, young, brash Osaka mayor Toru Hashimoto, who is also co-leader of an emerging conservative political party, also told reporters there was no clear evidence that the Japanese military coerced women to become what are euphemistically called “comfort women”.
He said: “To maintain discipline in the military, it must have been necessary at that time. For soldiers who risked their lives in circumstances where bullets are flying around like rain and wind, if you want them to get some rest, a comfort women system was necessary. That's clear to anyone.”
Historians say up to 200,000 women, mainly from the Korean Peninsula and China, were forced to provide sex for Japanese soldiers in military brothels.
An unidentified South Korean government official told Yonhap news agency it was disappointing that a senior Japanese official “made comments supportive of crimes against humanity and revealed a serious lack of a historical understanding and respect for women's rights”.
Mr Hashimoto's comments come amid mounting criticism at the prospect of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's conservative government revising Japan's past apologies for wartime atrocities.
Before he took office in December, Mr Abe had advocated revising a 1993 statement by then-Prime Minister Yohei Kono acknowledging and expressing remorse for the suffering caused to the sexual slaves of Japanese troops.
Mr Abe has acknowledged “comfort women” existed but has denied they were coerced into prostitution, citing a lack of official evidence.
Over the past two days, top officials in Mr Abe's government have appeared to ease their concern over Japan's past apologies, apparently to calm tensions with South Korea and China and address US concerns about his nationalist agenda.
Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga told reporters today that “the stance of the Japanese government on the comfort women issue is well known. They have suffered unspeakably painful experiences. The Abe Cabinet has the same sentiments as past Cabinets.”
Mr Hashimoto is co-head of the newly formed Japan Restoration Party with former Tokyo Governor Shintaro Ishihara, who is a strident nationalist.
AP
Send
Send
Recommend
Recommend
765764
This page has been shared 184 times. View these Tweets.
42
From around the web
Ads by Google

Independent Comment
Sorry, the browser you are using is not currently supported. Disqus actively supports the following browsers:
This page is forcing your browser to use legacy mode, which is not compatible with Disqus. Please see our troubleshooting guide to get more information about this error.
  • Joseph Kwan

    Growing up as a kid I would hear stories from my grandmother about the times in WW2 When the Japanese soldiers would line up women to Rape them. And brutal first hand accounts of insane behavior like using their swords to stick up the bottoms of babies in the villages and swirling them around. Lots of horrid stuff, I don't really want to get into.
    ... when I hear politicians drumming up nationlistic rehtoric, it makes me wonder if the Japanese people ever really learned their lesson.
    Its like Ghandi said, an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.
  • yota

    I'm Japanese.
    Please know there are many people in Japan who are against Hashimoto's remark. I also can't agree with his remark.
    But please also know this news article fail to express Hashimoto's true intentions. He said in news conference that there are various countries other than Japan have "comfort women" system in W.W.2. age. Hashimoto said "comfort women" is unforgivable now. But in that age "comfort women" are needed by military and this is unforgitable idea now, he said. He said "Why is only Jpan criticized?" In W.W.2., Vietnam war or the Korean War
    there are "comfort women". And he said we Japanese should apologize to comfort women.
    Those who want to know Hashimoto's intension, please see his news conference text and his twitter acount.
    http://synodos.jp/politics/389...
    https://twitter.com/t_ishin
    However these texts are Japanese. I can't tlanslate to English, because my English is poor. Please remember we Japanese are against wars as a country which throws away wars in our constitution.
  • John

    I am glad that the Japanese do not agree with this man's beliefs.
    But I do think this article reflected Hashimoto's true intentions. You and Hashimoto are arguing that because the Japanese used comfort women a long time ago and that other countries have used the system too, it is wrong to only criticize Japan.
    This is absolutely unacceptable because, first off, two wrongs don't make a right. Before crying out to the public and telling them, "But he did it too." if you seriously repent your crimes, you should stop caring about others committing the same crimes and start apologizing sincerely about your crimes. Also, just because something happened in the past doesn't make it acceptable now. A crime in the medival age for example is still a crime. True, as a civilization matures, there are growing number of activities that have become unacceptable. But, I assure you, raping or forced prostitution has never been acceptable.
    You said that many Japanese people do not agree with this fellow. You asked us, foreigners, to reevaluate his remarks by understanding his true intentions. I ask you to stop making excuses. This man is a high official in your government. He represents your people. If you believe that he is a false representation of the Japanese people, you should focus all your energy to change his belief by your participation in politics. After all, he does represent you. So stop asking us to understand him. Stop defending him. If you don't agree with him don't tell us that... Tell him that.
    Take a lesson from your WW2 Ally and see what they've done since the war. The world isn't stupid. We know what Japan did. Stop kidding yourself and take responsibility.
  • chrismusc

    Jeez, I despair, fascists in power still after all our experiences with The Japanese, Nazis, Francoites and Italians. There's even one running an English football club. And we've got fascist-lite UKIPITES running amok. As Ellison said,
    “The world is turning into a cesspool of imbeciles.”
  • britbob

    How about an apology and an addition that keeping these women as sex slaves was wrong.
  • Andrew

    There is plenty of evidence for the sex slaves, as per 1st hand accounts of survivors. I expect these denials are from the same quaters as the denials of japanese atrocities against civillian populations in occupied territories, most chiefly the Nan jing massacre.
  • dextersm

    this man is crazy, even by the standard of a politician. the japanese government might have apologized,but they are never serious about it.this comment is just so against human rights and so disrespectful to women
  • Jun Takao

    There are some Misunderstanding
    Leftists at okinawa are trying to remove USMC camp from okinawa island, but Hashimoto recognise it is necessary of the camp(for Japan& Taiwan). Leftist brame USMC troop's sexual crime in okinawa so he request USMC commander to aprove troops to use commercial sexual service in okinawa
    Regarding Fasist's Era's Japan Army he say "For avoid troops sexual crime,it was necessary Japanese Prostitute commercial sexual service" He never say "SEX SLAVE was necessary"
    And he is sorry to Duch Ladys who forced Sex slevery by stupid/shameless Japanese troops , about that Japan's War Crime.
  • Reiner Torheit

    There is not any misunderstanding.
    Take your vile fascist garbage elsewhere. You are sub-human.
    誤解がありません。
    他の場所であなたの下劣なファシストゴミを取る。あなたは、サブ人間である。
  • Jun Takao

    Why? If Japanese  Govt Deliverd Japanese Commercial Prostitute to Duch Indonesia, then the stupid Japanese troops need not caputure Duch Ladys as Sex Slaves. Actually troops are sometimes low level, so commanders and officers should provide enough food & domestic commercial prostitute to troops for avoiding troop's war crime. That is basic matter of logistics. Do not you think so? We regret our fatal logistics mistake
    But regarding Abe definitely he is a fascist BTW Pls move your capital to south ASAP Now DPRK artirally force take your capital as their hostage. That is why US cannot bombing DPRK's Nuke reactors. Your country give Nuke Terolists advantages.  
  • The_Seventh_Shape

    I wonder would Mr. Hashimoto be complaining if the Americans had lowered themselves to forcibly taking Japanese comfort women in the Japanese territories they occupied. Or does he have the intelligence to realize that his remarks implicitly advocate the general principle that soldiers have the right to forcibly make use of comfort women in war, Japanese or otherwise?
  • Anil Reddy

    my point is why the f..k did you wage a war in the first place......! i don't give a f... for communist chinese but why did you s...m bags start a war !!
  • Tony Camilleri

    How about his mother, wife, sisters and daughters doing the same job as these sex slaves? Disgusting Japanese mentality.
  • Cicero

    Anyone who has ever visited Yokusuni leaves in a cold fury that the Japanese can still attempt to whitewash the crimes committed by the militarist government. There is no doubt that Japan committed war crimes. Now, Japan continues to spread lies, to the fury of the Chinese who were their first and principal victims. Despite this, Japan still expects their security to be guaranteed by the US and by extension NATO- the UK should by vigorous in condemning this latest provocation, and forcing this odious man from office, since he is clearly unfit to hold it.
We were unable to load Disqus. If you are a moderator please see our troubleshooting guide.
× Comments for this thread are now closed.
No one has commented yet.

Top Discussions on News

    Top Commenters

      Nothing for you here ... yet. But as you comment with Disqus and follow other Disqus users, you will start to receive notifications here, as well as a personalized feed of activity by you and the people you follow. So get out there and participate in some discussions!
      × Disqus helps you find new and interesting content, discussions and products. Some sponsors and ecommerce sites may pay us for these recommendations and links. Learn more or give us feedback .

      Also on News

      Top stories
      News in pictures
      World news in pictures
      UK news in pictures
      UK news in pictures
      More stories
      Independent
      Travel Shop
      Summer Eurostar breaks
      Two nights and rail from only £109pp Find out more
      Lake Como and the Bernina Express
      Seven nights half-board from only £749pp Find out more
      All-inclusive Med cruise
      Seven nights from only £619pp Find out more
      Please provide search keyword(s)
       
      Adobe
      Produkte

      Suchen
       
      Info Anmelden
      Vorteile der Registrierung Als registrierter Anwender erhalten Sie Zugriff auf Ihr Konto, Testversionen, Produkterweiterungen, bestimmte Community-Bereiche u. v. m.
      Willkommen,
      Voraussichtliche Verfügbarkeit bei Vorbestellung Date. Ihre Kreditkartenkonto wird erst dann belastet, wenn das Produkt ausgeliefert wird. Änderungen des voraussichtlichen Verfügbarkeitsdatums sind vorbehalten. Voraussichtliche Verfügbarkeit bei Vorbestellung Date. Ihre Kreditkartenkonto wird erst dann belastet, wenn das Produkt zum Download bereit ist. Änderungen des voraussichtlichen Verfügbarkeitsdatums sind vorbehalten.
      Mge:
      (inkl.MwSt )
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.
      Zwischensumme (exkl. MwSt)
      Sonderaktionen
      Versand
      MwSt
      Gesamtsumme
      Gesamtsumme
      Datenschutz Mein Adobe

      Produkte

      Creative Cloud for teams

      5-mal mehr Cloud-Speicherplatz, intuitive Tools für die Lizenzverwaltung u. v. m.
      86,09
      pro Monat
      inkl. MwSt.

      Creative Cloud for teams

      5-mal mehr Cloud-Speicherplatz, intuitive Tools für die Lizenzverwaltung u. v. m.
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Creative Cloud Membership

      Alles, was Kreative brauchen – immer bereit, wann sie es brauchen
      61,49
      pro Monat
      inkl. MwSt.

      Creative Cloud Membership

      Alles, was Kreative brauchen – immer bereit, wann sie es brauchen
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Acrobat® XI Pro

      Entdecken Sie die volle PDF-Power von Acrobat XI.
      Upgrade ab
      284,13
      inkl. MwSt.

      Acrobat® XI Pro

      Entdecken Sie die volle PDF-Power von Acrobat XI.
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Dreamweaver

      Alle Tools für Design, Entwicklung und Bereitstellung von Websites und Apps
      24,59
      pro Monat
      inkl. MwSt.

      Dreamweaver

      Alle Tools für Design, Entwicklung und Bereitstellung von Websites und Apps
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Illustrator

      Leistungsstarke Werkzeuge für Vektorgrafik der Zukunft
      24,59
      pro Monat
      inkl. MwSt.

      Illustrator

      Leistungsstarke Werkzeuge für Vektorgrafik der Zukunft
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Photoshop

      Zeigen Sie der Welt Ihre Vision
      24,59
      pro Monat
      inkl. MwSt.

      Photoshop

      Zeigen Sie der Welt Ihre Vision
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Photoshop Elements 11

      Atemberaubend und doch so einfach: Bildbearbeitung in einer neuen Dimension
      Upgrade ab
      79,95
      inkl. MwSt.

      Photoshop Elements 11

      Atemberaubend und doch so einfach: Bildbearbeitung in einer neuen Dimension
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.

      Photoshop Lightroom 5

      Digitale Fotoentwicklung für professionelle Ansprüche.
      Upgrade ab
      76,26
      inkl. MwSt.

      Photoshop Lightroom 5

      Digitale Fotoentwicklung für professionelle Ansprüche.
      x
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.
      Alles, was Kreative brauchen – immer bereit, wann sie es brauchen
      Student and Teacher Edition
      Jahresabo ab
      61,49
      pro Monat
      inkl. MwSt.
      Für Ihre Bestellung ist ein Berechtigungsnachweis erforderlich.
      Ab Juni sind die neuen CC-Applikationen erhältlich.
       
      Telefonisch bestellen
      0800 - 752 25 80
      Neue Sparmöglichkeiten  beim Creative Cloud-Abo
      Region wählen Schließen
      North America
      Europe, Middle East and Africa
      Asia Pacific

      Copyright © 2013 Adobe Systems Software Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.
       
       .
       .
      SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone.
      SECURITY WARNING: Please treat the URL above as you would your password and do not share it with anyone.

      Recently Read

      Facebook
      Unshare A new social reading experience from The Independent, powered by Facebook. Learn More.
      Log In
      Be the first of your friends to use The Independent.
      SPONSORED FEATURES

      Learn a new language

      Add another string to your bow with Rosetta Stone, whether it's Spanish, Italian or Mandarin...

      Making reading fun for kids

      Nook is donating eReaders to volunteers at high-need schools and participating in exclusive events throughout the campaign.
      Ads by Google

      Independent Dating
      and  
      By clicking 'Search' you
      are agreeing to our
      Terms of Use.
      iJobs Job Widget
      iJobs General

      ICT Teacher

      £22000 - £31500 per annum: Capita Education Resourcing Permanent Team: Are you...

      Nursery Nurse

      £15000 - £18000 per annum: Capita Education Resourcing Permanent Team: Looking...

      Reception Teacher

      £22000 - £31500 per annum: Capita Education Resourcing Permanent Team: Are you...

      Teacher of English, Medway, Kent

      £21000 - £32000 per annum: Capita Education Resourcing Permanent Team: Looking...

      Day In a Page


      .