CLEVELAND – Sandy Buchanan, Ohio Citizen Action Executive Director, announced today that the organization had closed its Money in Politics Project after 18 years.

Buchanan said, “The Money in Politics Project has been the authoritative source for data and analysis of the role of big money in Ohio politics.

In 1999, it won a multi-year campaign to enact electronic reporting of campaign contributions in Ohio.  Since then, it has published dozens of studies on the role of money in Ohio politics, assisting reporters in uncovering the spider webs of campaign contributions, and supporting key legislation to reform Ohio’s election and campaign finance laws.”

“The organization is now strengthening its focus on pollution — coal, fracking, and alternatives to the proposed Cleveland incinerator. We’ve just had a string of victories, on Baard Energy, Cincinnati electric aggregation, the Englewood canvassing case and FirstEnergy’s four Lake Erie coal plants. We want to keep the victories coming. The more focused you are, the more likely you are to succeed.”

“Of course, political corruption is part of most pollution issues. We’ll still be wrestling with money in politics, but on a campaign by campaign basis, not as a separate project.”

Ohio treasurer ran for office criticizing hiring practices of incumbent

COLUMBUS — “Republican Josh Mandel hired young, relatively inexperienced staffers from his 2010 campaign and gave them high-ranking jobs in the state treasurer’s office, a Dayton Daily News examination found.

It’s fairly common for newly elected office holders to hire people they know, but Mandel’s hires stand out because of the strong stance the then state representative took against incumbent Democrat Kevin Boyce’s hiring practices during the heated 2010 race for treasurer….

‘It’s really difficult for our officeholders not to feel beholden to those that surrounded them in the campaign, but they have a responsibility to hire the most qualified people,’ said Catherine Turcer of Ohio Citizen Action, a nonpartisan good-government watchdog group. She added: ‘Josh Mandel had a responsibility to hire the most capable applicants, not the most politically connected ones.’” Laura Bischoff, Dayton Daily News.

Read the whole story

COLUMBUS — “Do John and Jane Ohioan have a right to attend public meetings without identifying themselves?  The question is playing out in court in Trumbull County, where a judge has refused a request to order the children services board to allow members of the public to attend meetings without signing a registration sheet, according to The Vindicator of Youngstown.

Ohio law grants Ohioans an unqualified right of access to public meetings with no seeming conditions. Ohioans are not required to identify themselves to obtain public records, so why should they have to sign a piece of paper or fork over an ID to attend a public meeting?

Security and safety considerations — cited as the need for a public sign-in procedure at the Trumbull County Children Services board meetings — are far from unique.” Randy Ludlow, The Columbus Dispatch.

Read the whole story

COLUMBUS– “The role of the Ohio Elections Commission is to enforce campaign finance laws, not to figure out ways around them.

So the commission played the public for suckers Thursday — despite a Plain Dealer editorial that exposed the errors, false assumptions and failure of due diligence in its prior ruling — when it punted on whether to let a convicted felon, former Cuyahoga County Sheriff Gerald McFaul, use campaign contributions to pay court-ordered restitution. The panel also violated state law….

Husted told Plain Dealer reporter Joe Guillen he would wait until that opinion was issued before taking further action.  If the commission wishes to cease being an embarrassment and become the watchdog it’s supposed to be, it will reverse the McFaul ruling and apply a more professional standard in the future.” The Plain Dealer.

Read the whole story

COLUMBUS — “Nearly four years after former Attorney General Marc Dann stepped down in disgrace, his livelihood — practicing law — rests with the Ohio Supreme Court….

The high court’s disciplinary counsel wants to make an example of Dann and see him lose his license for six months….

The Democrat later pleaded guilty to filing false financial-disclosure statements stemming from flying on a private jet chartered by a one-time gambling lobbyist, a misdemeanor. He stopped short of admitting guilt on another misdemeanor — paying two aides in the attorney general’s office from his campaign account — but it was treated as a guilty plea for sentencing purposes.” David Eggert, The Columbus Dispatch.

Read the whole story

Ohio Supreme Court to decide former attorney general’s law license suspension

Kelly Gifford, The Plain Dealer.

U.S. Senator McCain talks during a panel discussion on the influence of money in politics at the Newseum in Washington.

WASHINGTON, DC — “McCain, speaking at a Reuters forum on money in politics, gave a blistering critique of U.S. Supreme Court justices over a 2010 ruling that lifted limits on political fundraising and spending by corporations, unions and other non-campaign groups by equating their rights to those of individual citizens.

The decision led to the creation of ‘Super PACs,’ political action committees that have had outsized impacts on state and local political campaigns and are changing the face of the 2012 presidential election by dumping roughly $100 million into ads, most of which have attacked candidates.

‘What the Supreme Court did is a combination of arrogance, naivete and stupidity the likes of which I have never seen,’ said McCain, one of the authors of a now partially overturned law that restricted political spending by corporations and other outside groups.

‘I promise you, there will be huge scandals,’ McCain said, ‘because there’s too much money washing around, too much of it we don’t know who’s behind it and too much corruption associated with that kind of money. There will be major scandals.’” — Reuters

Read the whole story

New York City public advocate Bill de Blasio speaks outside the SEC on Monday morning in Washington.

NEW YORK, NY — “Some campaign reformers have thus turned their attention to the Securities and Exchange Commission, urging it to pass a rule that all publicly traded companies must disclose political spending to shareholders—this would reveal exactly what business interests are trying to influence the election, and in the eyes of most experts, lead to dramatically reduced corporate electioneering.

In his opinion in Citizen’s United, Justice Anthony Kennedy incorrectly asserted that shareholders would be in the loop on political spending, but there’s actually no such requirement. One SEC commissioner, Luis Aguilar, already said he would support a disclosure rule on public corporations. Only two more votes would be needed to pass the rule—and reformers are pushing hard. They held a demonstration outside the SEC this morning, aiming to tell the SEC the “clock is ticking” on disclosure and that it’s “time to wake up.” (Hence the above-pictured human alarm clock).

— The Nation

Read the whole story

The Gerrymander is officially “celebrating” its 200th anniversary.  The political cartoon-map that early on captured the problem with misshapen districts and maps drawn for partisan advantage first appeared in the Boston Gazette on March 26, 1812.

Top Ten Reasons for Ohioans to Reject Gerrymandering

1. Ohio’s new Congressional Districts now look like they were drawn using an Etch A Sketch.

2. Ohio’s new 9th Congressional District is so narrow that with a good long jump you could leap right over it — from the 4th District, right in to Lake Erie.

3. The mapmakers put The Ohio State University and Ohio University in the same Congressional District instead of the NCAA Elite 8.

4. Tax-payers had to foot the bill for a fancy hotel room1 — the politicians called “The Bunker” — so the mapmakers could have more privacy to gerrymander Ohio’s new Congressional and State Legislative districts.2

5. Washington political leaders had more of a voice drawing Ohio’s lines than most members of the Ohio’s General Assembly.3

6. Washington politicians directed the mapmakers to include Timken headquarters in an incumbent Congressman’s district in order to maximize contributions to his campaign.4

7. The mapmakers came up with a brand new criteria for redistricting called, ‘Save Our Politicians Millions in Future Campaign Spending.’ 5

8. Partisan operatives got $150,000 to help draw the maps.6  Ohio’s voters got the shaft.

9. Mapmakers ignored public input and protected their own political interests. Their efforts made a mockery of public redistricting hearings held across the state.

10. Congressional districts were rigged so that most U.S. Representatives were selected during the Primary, robbing millions of General Election voters of a voice. 7

Footnotes:

  1. Map-makers worked in Room 601 of the Double Tree Guest Suites, The Elephant in the Room, Appendix p. 31-34
  2. Apportionment Board Secretary Ray DiRossi’s August 16, 2011 email at 9:53am noted, “I’m free all day today at the Bunker,” The Elephant in the Room, Appendix p. 35
  3. Ray DiRossi sent an email to Ohio Senate President Niehaus on September 12, 2011 reporting that director of Team Boehner Tom “Whatman signed off” on district line, The Elephant in the Room, Appendix p. 74.  Also on p. 86 DiRossi notes in an email “DC is increasingly pushing to put a lid on this.”
  4. Tom Whatman of Team Boehner requested the Timken manufacturing plant be added to Rep. Renacci’s district in an email, The Elephant in the Room, pp. 99-101
  5. Ohio House Speaker’s Chief of Staff Troy Judy provided Ray DiRossi with an analysis which ranked the top Ohio House Districts for the amount of in-kind campaign support provide by the Republican Party or caucuses.  DiRoss replied, “But we have made significant improvements to many HD on this list.  Hopefully, saving millions over the coming years,” The Elephant in the Room, Appendix 106-107.
  6. Both Apportionment Board Secretaries received contracts for $75,000 for map-making. Each received an additional $30,000 for their work during litigation, Elephant in the Room, Appendix pp. 41-46.
  7. Partisan indexing based on the results of the following statewide races: 2008 – Present.
  8. 2010 – Governor, Auditor, and Secretary of State project no highly or heavily competitive Congressional races in 2012.

“‘When the Founders put together this great experiment in freedom we call America,’ [U.S. Rep. Jim Jordan] said, ‘they wanted the members of the House of Representatives to be as close to the people as possible.’

But without compact and contiguous districts, that’s impossible. Without a sea change in the way Ohio draws its districts, the will of the people won’t mean much.

The hyperpartisan gerrymandering that divided Ohio after the 2010 Census allowed politicians to pick voters, not the other way around. District lines that arbitrarily split counties, townships, cities, and villages were purely political calculations. Ohio voters deserve better. A coalition of citizen advocacy groups, led by the League of Women Voters of Ohio, filed petitions with the Ohio attorney general this week to reform state redistricting with a constitutional amendment.” — Marilou Johanek, Toledo Blade.

Read the whole story

Voters First Ohio  www.votersfirstohio.org

COLUMBUS — “Ohio State Treasurer Josh Mandel has missed 14 Board of Deposit meetings since taking office in January 2011, Watchdog10’s Paul Aker reported Wednesday.

Until Monday, Mandel had missed every one of the committee meetings, of which he acts as chair.

…’Nothing is more irritating than when public officials miss public (meetings) to raise money,’ said Ohio Citizen Action’s Catherine Turcer.

Turcer said that Mandel’s attendance record was unacceptable.

‘The problem is, half of doing a job right is showing up,’ Turcer said.

Watchdog10 uncovered that previous treasurer Kevin Boyce attended 11 of 24 meetings, and Richard Cordray only missed one.

‘We do need to understand that our treasurer does not need to come to every meeting, but never attending or just coming to one to make a big show after you’ve been so heavily criticized is a problem,’ Turcer said.” —  Paul Aker, 10TV

Read the whole story

Undoing law would cancel fall referendum sought by Democrats

COLUMBUS — “At the request of Democrats who oppose the measure, Senate Republicans agreed today to delay a vote to repeal House Bill 194, the election overhaul law approved last year that Democrats and progressive groups are working to overturn on the November ballot.

…Republicans, including Secretary of State Jon Husted, have pushed to repeal the law and remove the referendum from the November ballot, arguing that the debate over election laws could cause confusion for voters and will cost an estimated $1 million.

Republicans say they are just giving House Bill 194 opponents what they want – and doing it with certainty, instead of leaving it to the whim of voters in the fall. But Democrats argue that after collecting hundreds of thousands of signatures, the coalition pushing to overturn the law deserves a vote in November.” — Jim Siegel, Columbus Dispatch.

Read the whole story

NEW YORK, NY — “The Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision opened up the way for unlimited corporate spending on politics and has led to the proliferation of non-profit political groups that do not have to disclose the identities of their donors. But it turns out corporations may be getting another benefit from anonymous donations they give to these groups: a break on their taxes.

It all starts with the so-called ‘social welfare’ groups that have become bigger players in the political world in the wake of Citizens United, which knocked down restrictions on campaign activity by such groups.

Tax experts say it’s possible that businesses are using an aggressive interpretation of the law to wring a tax advantage out of their donations to these groups.” — Justin Elliott, ProPublica.

Read the whole story

The Application of the Gift Tax Provisions in the Internal Revenue Code to § 501(c)(4) Organizations

— Donal B Tobin, Moritz College of Law

State officials take exception to report

COLUMBUS — “The arrest of a state lawmaker last week on corruption charges provided fodder for a new national study released today that says state governments, including Ohio, are ripe for corruption. It says states do a poor job of delivering transparency and accountability to their citizenry.

…Catherine Turcer, a government watchdog with Ohio Citizen Action, said she found some of the grades assessed the state as unduly harsh. Senate President Tom Niehaus, R-New Richmond, Chris Davey, a spokesman for the Ohio Supreme Court, and Paul M. Nick, executive director of the Ohio Ethics Commission, also took exception to the report.

Turcer, Bledsoe and Nick were all contacted when the Ohio portion of the study was being conducted.

‘I wonder,’ Turcer said, ‘if this is about encouraging us to have a discussion about what makes a good democracy.’” — Paul E. Kostyu, Cincinnati Enquirer.

Read the whole story

Dayton completed the records request within two months

COLUMBUS — “Yost released the results Monday to celebrate Sunshine Week, a national effort advocating open government and freedom of information. The auditor’s office is not seeking any legal action against any of the cities, rather the exercise was intended to evaluate the process at the city level.

‘These are the public’s documents,’ Yost said. ‘The government belongs to the people. The documents belong to the people.’

Yost said if his office has a hard time collecting “routine documents,” the average citizen won’t be able to do it.

Yost also said public records battles could be costly for local governments and suggested policy makers look for ways besides costly litigation to hold accountable public entities for their records responsibilities.

‘Although public records law in Ohio is alive it’s not particularly well,’ Yost said.” — Jackie Borchardt, Springfield Sun-News

Read the whole story

This is Sunshine Week which is an initiative to promote a national dialogue about the need for open government, open records and to promote your right to know.   http://www.sunshineweek.org/

Columbus lawmaker indicted on bribery, other charges

After his indictment today, state Rep. W. Carlton Weddington, D-Columbus, is booked by a Franklin County sheriff's deputy. Chris Russell | Dispatch

COLUMBUS “State Rep. W. Carlton Weddington of Columbus surrendered to the FBI today and resigned his seat in the legislature after he became what officials say is the first sitting state lawmaker in Ohio indicted on a bribery charge in 100 years.

The FBI set up an elaborate undercover sting against Weddington, creating a phony businesses entity that spent more than $16,000 to send the two-term Democrat on lavish, all-expenses-paid trips to Miami and Napa Valley, Calif., plus cash and campaign contributions. In exchange, Weddington agreed to introduce legislation on the entity’s behalf, said Edward Hanko, FBI special agent in charge of the Cincinnati field office.

Weddington also failed to publicly disclose the trips and contributions on his campaign-finance filings and his financial-disclosure report, authorities allege.” — Jim Siegel, Columbus Dispatch

Read the whole story

Jimmy Dimora, left, and his attorney William Whitaker, outside the U.S. District Courthouse in Akron.

CLEVELAND — “Since FBI agents fanned across Cuyahoga County in July 2008, raiding the homes and offices of public officials and contractors, Catherine Turcer has served as the voice of citizen outrage.

The legislative director of watchdog group Ohio Citizen Action, Turcer has spoken against corruption and in favor of reform. She’s been the go-to person for reporters looking to put in perspective all the schemes and the costs to taxpayers.

And now that former county Commissioner Jimmy Dimora has been led away in chains, convicted of racketeering and other corruption-related crimes?

‘It’s a huge sigh of relief for the voters in Cuyahoga County,’ Turcer said Friday. ‘It shows the system works. It provides some closure to the story.’

…’The price of democracy is vigilance, she said. ‘We all need to be more vigilant. We need as many eyes as possible on the government.’” — Laura Johnston, Cleveland Plain Dealer

Read the whole story

High court decision ensures public access to property records

COLUMBUS — “A recent Ohio Supreme Court ruling smacking down Cuyahoga County’s attempt to charge extortionate fees for providing public information isn’t a victory just for real-estate professionals and wonky journalists who might be interested in copious mortgage data. It is a victory for the public, against a highhanded attempt to effectively disregard public-records law.

Obtaining public information that already exists in electronic form should be simple and routine, and it was in the Cuyahoga County recorder’s office until 2010….

That’s when Recorder Lillian Greene informed two California real estate-information companies that her office no longer would provide a CD of each day’s transactions for $50. Instead, she said she would provide only paper copies of the documents, at the premium price of $2 per page.” The Columbus Dispatch.

Read the whole story

AKRON — “By Friday, Husted had given a welcome endorsement to the constitutional amendment drafted by the bipartisan gang of four, his stamp of approval based on the sound principles that guided his own effort: Redistricting reform should be kept as simple as possible, with emphasis on bipartisan cooperation rather than complex formulas to design districts according to given criteria….

Husted’s realistic fear is that the gang of four’s plan will get hopelessly bogged down if, as is being suggested by William Batchelder, a fellow Republican and House speaker, it first must go through a legislative task force and then a special constitutional study commission.

The commission, co-chaired by Batchelder, is set to make an initial report no later than Jan. 1, an amendment thus unlikely to make the November ballot this year. Even now, some Democrats are leaning toward the citizens groups because their plan would go into effect in 2014. Finally, Husted has an astute warning: The longer Republicans stay in power, the less likely they will be to support any plan creating a bipartisan commission.” Akron Beacon Journal.

Read the whole story

Read the response from Voters First Ohio to this bipartisan politicians proposal

COLUMBUS — “Democratic backers of the November ballot issue to repeal a newly passed election reform law say the state needs to leave the issue alone right now and allow it to go to the ballot as planned. Former Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner says repealing the law and replacing it now with a new one would likely disenfranchise some voters.Brunner says she’d like to see in person voting the weekend before the election restored for November and be in place like it was back in 2008. Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted says he wants the legislature to repeal the election reform law now. And he says if anything is put in place to replace it now, that legislation should be bipartisan.

Former SOS disagrees with replacing law

Brunner said repealing law will lose voters

Democratic backers of the November ballot issue to repeal a newly passed election reform law say the state needs to leave the issue alone right now and allow it to go to the ballot as planned. Former Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner says repealing the law and replacing it now with a new one would likely disenfranchise some voters. Jo Ingles, Statehouse News Bureau.
Windows Media / MP3 Download (0:20)

For Information about voting in Ohio, click on this link.