Skip to Main Content

Phillies vs. Giants: 2010 NLCS

10/12/2010 3:10 AM ET By Pat Lackey

AText Size
    • Pat Lackey
    • MLB Writer
If October baseball is about pitching, this year's NLCS, pitting the Philadelphia Phillies against the San Francisco Giants, has it in spades. The Giants led the National League in ERA and allowed the second fewest runs in the league. The Phillies were fourth in runs allowed, but adding Roy Oswalt to Roy Halladay and Cole Hamels at midseason gives them perhaps the most vaunted 1-2-3 rotation punch in all of baseball.

After great regular seasons, both teams' pitching staffs have come through with big playoff performances. Roy Halladay no-hit the National League's best offense in his first playoff performance and Cole Hamels followed shortly after with a complete-game shutout of his own to close out the Reds. Tim Lincecum was nearly as good as Halladay, striking out 14 and shutting out the Braves' offense in Game 1, then Jonathan Sanchez struck out 11 Braves in Game 3. Those two performances are the two highest strikeout totals in the Giants' franchise's long playoff history.

For a third straight season, the NLCS will feature the Phillies against the NL West champion. In 2008 and 2009, the Dodgers only managed two wins total (one each year), as the Phillies brought back-to-back pennants to Philadelphia. This year the Phillies shoot for their third pennant in a row, while the Giants try for their first since 2002 and just their third of the division era.

Halladay vs. Lincecum. Oswalt vs. Matt Cain. Sanchez vs. Hamels. That's what we've got lined up through the first three games of the NLCS without even mentioning Chase Utley, Jayson Werth, Ryan Howard, Buster Posey, Aubrey Huff, or Andres Torres. So which pitching staff is the National League's best? Which offense can break through for enough runs to carry its team to a pennant?



Series Schedule

Date Game TV Time (ET)
Oct. 16 San Francisco Giants at Philadelphia Phillies FOX 7:57 p.m.
Oct. 17 San Francisco Giants at Philadelphia Phillies FOX 8:19 p.m.
Oct. 19 Philadelphia Phillies at San Francisco Giants FOX 4:19 p.m.
Oct. 20 Philadelphia Phillies at San Francisco Giants FOX 7:57 p.m.
Oct. 21 Philadelphia Phillies at San Francisco Giants, if necessary FOX 7:57 p.m.
Oct. 23 San Francisco Giants at Philadelphia Phillies, if necessary FOX 3:57/7:57 p.m.
Oct. 24 San Francisco Giants at Philadelphia Phillies, if necessary FOX 7:57 p.m.


Why the Phillies Will Win

Because the Reds had gone 15 years without a playoff appearane and weren't expected to contend in the NL Central this year, I think there's a tendency to underestimate just how good of a baseball team they were, especially on the offensive side. The Reds led the National League in most important offensive categories this year and were healthy for their series against the Phillies. Then they got steamrolled by the Phillies' pitching staff, especially Halladay and Hamels. Those two held the Reds to just five hits and one walk over 18 innings, striking out 17 hitters and never allowing more than four batters in any inning in Games 1 and 3. It was as dominant as pitching gets, and it was against an offense that was much deeper and more accomplished this year than the one the Giants will be sending out in this series.

With their three wins against Cincinnati figured in, the Phillies are 26-7 since September started. That includes five wins in six tries against the Braves team the Giants just squeaked past in their own Division Series. In the four games the Giants played against Atlanta, they outscored the Braves by two runs total. In the six games the Phillies played against the same Braves team since Sept. 20 (including some games before Martin Prado was injured), the Phils outscored the Braves 25-17.

It's the Phillies' pitching staff that everyone talks about, but it's the offense that could make the difference for them in this series. The Giants just can't match hitters like Chase Utley, Ryan Howard, or Jayson Werth. Howard was last year's NLCS MVP and Utley is coming off of a strong Division Series. Someone is eventually going to have to score runs in this series, and at least at the outset of the series, the Phillies' lineup is much more likely to figure out the Giants' rotation than vice versa.

Phillies Projected Roster

Lineup Bench Rotation Bullpen
Jimmy Rollins (SS) Brian Schneider (C) Roy Halladay (RHP) Brad Lidge (RHP)
Placido Polanco (3B) Wilson Valdez (IF) Roy Oswalt (RHP) Ryan Madson (RHP)
Chase Utley (2B) Mike Sweeney (1B) Cole Hamels (LHP) Jose Contreras (RHP)
Ryan Howard (1B) Ben Francisco (OF) Joe Blanton (RHP) Chad Durbin (RHP)
Jayson Werth (RF) Domonic Brown (OF) Antonio Bastardo (LHP)
Shane Victorino (CF) Ross Gload (UT) J.C. Romero (LHP)
Raul Ibanez (LF) Greg Dobbs (IF)
Carlos Ruiz (C)
Pitcher's Spot


Why the Giants Will Win

As good as the Philies' offense looks on paper, they were mostly shut down by a Reds pitching staff that's vastly inferior to the one the Giants will be sending out to the mound in this series. If Bronson Arroyo and Johnny Cueto are causing problems for an offense, what happens when they face Tim Lincecum? Halladay's no-hitter is rightly getting a great majority of the publicity, but Lincecum's 14-strikeout two-hitter was nearly as dazzling, and if his changeup and Jonathan Sanchez's slider look anything like the pitches the Braves flailed helplessly at, the Phillies may find that they won't have much more luck scoring runs than their division rivals.

As much as the Giants' lineup doesn't stack up man for man with the Phillies, the Giants did get solid NLDS performances from Aubrey Huff, Cody Ross and rookie Buster Posey. They didn't score a ton of runs, but they came up with the hits and runs they needed in both Games 3 and 4 and won both contests, despite trailing or being tied late. Maybe some poor Atlanta fielding helped them along the way, but the Phillies got the same benefit in Game 2 against the Reds. The Phillies have more talent on offense, but if they hit the way they did against the Reds that won't do much for them.

Remember that a best-of-seven series is still a short series. Roy Halladay is one of the best pitchers alive right now, but so is Lincecum. Remember, he's the two-time defending NL Cy Young winner and might have been right in the mix for the award again this year except for a midseason slump that's now well behind him (beside his incredible start against the Braves, he put up a 1.94 ERA and averaged more than a strikeout an inning in six September and October starts). That means no matter what Halladay does in Game 1, the Phillies could find themselves down a game facing Matt Cain, who looked much better in the Division Series than his probable mound opponent Roy Oswalt did. After that, it's Jonathan Sanchez pitching at home in San Francisco. That's not an enviable position for any team to be in, no matter who their starters are. That's simply to say that in a best-of-seven series, there's not a lot of room for error even for a team as talented as the Phillies, and the Giants' pitching staff puts them in position to take advantage of any openings the Phillies give them.

Giants Projected Roster

Lineup Bench Rotation Bullpen
Andres Torres (CF) Mike Fontenot (2B) Tim Lincecum (RHP) Brian Wilson (RHP)
Freddy Sanchez (2B) Nate Schierholtz (OF) Matt Cain (RHP) Jeremy Affeldt (LHP)
Aubrey Huff (1B) Aaron Rowand (OF) Jonathan Sanchez (LHP) Sergio Romo (RHP)
Buster Posey (C) Travis Ishikawa (IF) Madison Bumgarner (LHP) Javier Lopez (LHP)
Pat Burrell (LF) Eli Whiteside (C) Guillermo Mota (RHP)
Juan Uribe (SS) Edgar Renteria (IF) Santiago Casilla (RHP)
Cody Ross (RF) Ramon Ramirez (RHP)
Pablo Sandoval (3B)
Pitcher's Spot


Prediction

The bottom line is that the Phillies are the favorites here. Halladay and Lincecum may be a wash head-to-head, but Halladay is capable of pitching three games in the series where Lincecum will likely only go two (he's never started on three days of rest in his career). Hamels has an NLCS MVP and a World Series MVP to his name and if his start against Cincinnati is any indication, he's back in the form that won him both awards two years ago. The Giants' top three may be as talented as the Phillies', but the Phils have two pitchers that have pitched deep into the playoffs before to go with Halladay, while the Giants' young staff has never been this deep in the postseason.

And though the Giants' offense got the job done against the Braves, they just don't seem deep enough to really challenge that Philly pitching staff, especially since they'll have to outscore the Phillies' lineup. I think that their excellent pitching and a unique home field get the Giants one more win than the Dodgers got in either of the last two seasons, but I'm not going to believe an NL team can take the Phillies out until I see it. PHILLIES IN SIX.

Read More:     , , , , , , , , , ,


Today's Best From MLB FanHouse

Comments (Page 1 of 1)

GOT SOMETHING TO SAY?

iPhone Apps

FanHouse

Check Out FanHouse's iPhone app.
FanHouse for iPhone is Here!
Our iPhone app delivers the latest sports news straight to your iPhone or iPod touch, instantly - powered by the best writing staff on the Web.

Fantasy Sports

Check Out Fleaflickers new iPhone app.
Follow your favorite pro players and teams from anywhere like never before with fantasy enhanced box scores, live leader boards, expert analysis and customizable watch lists.

MMA Fighting

Check Out Fleaflickers new iPhone app.
MMAFighting.com is a premier destination for MMA fans looking for breaking news, provocative commentary and extensive event coverage that reflects our love of MMA -- and yours.
FanHouse.com

Get NFL, NBA, MLB, NHL, NASCAR and college sports news from FanHouse including stats, scores, results, and player updates from pro and college leagues.

Aol Sports. Back To The Top