The World's Worst Textbooks

As students around the world head back to school, many of the lessons they're learning are not only false -- they're dangerous.

BY SUZANNE MERKELSON | SEPTEMBER 7, 2010

UNITED STATES

Lesson plan: Culture Wars 101

Subject matter: The Texas Board of Education ignited an international firestorm last spring when members approved a controversial new social studies curriculum. The new standards skew hard to the right -- championing American capitalism throughout and suggesting religious intentions on the part of the founding fathers.

Some of the most notable arguments were over language surrounding U.S. imperialism (now known as "expansionism") and birth control pioneer Margaret Sanger as a promoter of "eugenics," and an amendment to teachers that students be instructed to "describe the causes and key organizations and individuals of the conservative resurgence of the 1980s and 1990s, including Phyllis Schlafly, the Contract with America, the Heritage Foundation, the Moral Majority and the National Rifle Association." The board even recommended that Thomas Jefferson, creator of the expression "separation of church and state" be excluded from a list of world thinkers who inspired Enlightenment-era revolutions. And, in a salute to Democrats, "Bill Clinton's impeachment" will join Watergate in lessons on "political scandals."

The curriculum standards are reviewed every decade and serve as a template for textbook publishers. Texas's 4.8 million public school students make the state one of the largest markets for textbooks and a determinant of what the rest of the country's schoolchildren will study, with national publishers often tailoring their texts to Texas standards.

Primary source: The new curriculum hasn't hit textbooks yet, but pop quizzes are expected to have a slightly different look -- Newsweek recently published new study exercises that the Texas school board is likely to adopt:

"Explain how Arab rejection of the State of Israel has led to ongoing conflict."  And "Evaluate efforts by global organizations to undermine U.S. sovereignty.

Getty Images

 

Suzanne Merkelson is an editorial assistant at Foreign Policy.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit
 SUBJECTS: EDUCATION

ANTHONY DONALDSON

11:03 PM ET

September 7, 2010

The US Navy blockaded China to cause starvation:

THIS article is revisionist in ignoring that the USA, slapped a FOOD EMBARGO on China, specifically, to starve the Chinese people, hoping that mass starvation would destroy the country.
.
From the Asia Times article:

"Bad weather, famines and the US trade embargo caused most of the deaths."
.
SOURCE:
http://www.atimes.com/atimes/C­hina/FD01Ad04.html
.
FURTHERMORE, the USA pressured Canada & Australia to starve China by withholding food.
.
Imagine the hypcrisy of the US calling itself Champion of Human Rights while conducting GENOCIDE on a Nation for their political leanings.
.
The US desrves a huge share of the blame for Killing so many Chinese people via starvation.

  REPLY
 

DR. KUCHBHI

11:31 PM ET

September 7, 2010

Red Indians and Thanksgiving

I don't recollect any stats or history in US textbooks about the history of Native Americans or about the multitude of treaties made and broken with them, or their slow but sure extermination, relegating them to less than the dust heap of history...

  REPLY
 

OPEMILY

9:56 AM ET

September 8, 2010

I studied the history of

I studied the history of relations between the United States and Native Americans in my high school history class. It was clearly a white-washed version, overlooking the gravity of the atrocities that were committed- but I remember discussing it.

Not to excuse the content of these books, but I don't know if a textbook from religion studies is really the best way to go. Also picking out the most controversial lines from these books doesn't really give you a sense of what these books actually contain.

It would be a much better article if you reduced the variables. Choose one age level, one subject (history seems to be the most informative), and find passages describing significant events. It would be interesting to compare the narration of the Iranian Revolution as it is taught to Iranian, Saudi, or American students.

Or even better, get copies of tests that were given to students. It would be a peek not only at the textbook, but what the teacher goes over in class as well.

  REPLY
 

BILL888

2:25 AM ET

September 8, 2010

Elementary School or High School text books?

The author did not say if these text books are for elementary or high school. He did included some elementary students photos on this article. It is very like that the text books are for high school. For the China text books he wrote about the missing Tibet invasion, Mao's great leap forward, the reason and judge on what caused the defeat of Japanese in world. But I am totally disappointed why he stopped by just mentioning a few only. The author should started naming all the missing events starting...say, two thousands five hundred years ago:

1. The birth confuscius ans Lou zhi and the reason why some teachings are outed.
2. The assimilations of certain groups of namadic tribes into the Chinese Han cultures.
3. The names and make up off all the warring nations before China is unified.
....
....
400. The first Chinese Lady Empress in Tang dynasty who held real power.
.....
....
500. The reason Tang Dynasty was weakened due to the Muslim general's revolt.
...
...
...1001. The Qing Emperor who lead a war and killed the Mongolian Khan who invaded the empire and conseqently made his sister a widower from the killing.
...
...
1367. The boxer repellion and why it happened.
...
...
2110. The boarding of the Chinese cargo ship, Galaxy, heading for Iran and stopped American war ship and found no military cargos.
....
2367. The bombing of Chinese Embassy by Nato in Serbia.
.....
....
....more...more...

The author had just written this article for kidding.
Every body laughs.....

  REPLY
 

BILL888

2:31 AM ET

September 8, 2010

I mean the text books are for elementary schoolers

...He did included some elementary students photos on this article. It is very like that the text books are for elementary school. For the China text...

  REPLY
 

BILL888

3:16 AM ET

September 8, 2010

I am sorry: the author is a 'her'

Sorry for my mistake.

  REPLY
 

NICOLAS19

4:19 AM ET

September 8, 2010

citations needed

Without proper citation - author/editor, publisher, year of publication, edition, page number - this article is nothing but a shameless, political smear campaign. "seventh grade (...) textbook" is hardly a verifiable source. Back your accusations up with facts! Without background data, this is just irresponsible, hate-spreading journalism, unworthy of FP.

  REPLY