Toronto gets ‘secret’ arrest powers ahead of G20 protests

By Daniel Tencer
Friday, June 25th, 2010 -- 3:00 pm

torontog20 Toronto gets secret arrest powers ahead of G20 protests

TORONTO -- A government changes a law to allow police to arrest people without probable cause. It does so without any legislative debate. Then it keeps the change a virtual secret, until someone is arrested under those new powers.

The Soviet Union circa 1950? Nope. Try Canada, June 2010.

Civil liberties advocates and political activists are up in arms after it emerged Friday that police in Toronto have been given special powers to arrest anyone near the site of the G20 summit if they fail to identify themselves.

What's more, the government of the province of Ontario, which green-lit the new powers, didn't tell anyone about it until after someone was arrested under the new powers.

Thirty-one-year-old Dave Vasey was arrested near the G20 perimeter security fence in downtown Toronto Thursday afternoon after refusing to identify himself to a police officer.

Story continues below...

“The officer told me, ‘I am going to have to place you under arrest if you don’t show your identification,’ and I replied ‘I’m not comfortable with that,’” Vasey said, as quoted at the Toronto Star.

With Vasey's arrest, it emerged that Ontario secretly changed its Public Works Protection Act to allow police officers unprecedented powers of arrest. That law allowed police to arrest people if they fail to identify themselves to a police officer when inside a government building or near a "public works" project. It has now been expanded to include the area around the G20 summit, meaning a significant portion of downtown Toronto.

The Toronto Star reports:

The regulation kicked in Monday and will expire June 28, the day after the summit ends. While the new regulation appeared without notice on the province’s e-Laws online database last week, it won’t be officially published in The Ontario Gazette until July 3 — one week after the regulation expires.

According to the new regulation, “guards” appointed under the act can arrest anyone who, in specific areas, comes within five metres of the security zone.

Within those areas, police can demand identification from anyone coming within five metres of the fence perimeter and search them. If they refuse, they face arrest. Anyone convicted under the regulation could also face up to two months in jail or a $500 maximum fine.

Toronto Chief of Police Bill Blair, who reportedly requested the arrest powers, denied Friday that it had been done in secret.

“We haven’t changed the rules," he said, as quoted at the National Post. "We have put up a fence. We have told people very very clearly that we will not be allowing the public access into that area. ... Our authority comes primarily comes from common law, but also by the regulation that has been passed by the province of Ontario."

But the assertion that the change wasn't secret was immediately challenged by reporters covering the G20 summit.

"Funny," writes Adam Radwanski at the Globe and Mail, "I asked two different spokespeople for the integrated G20 police unit — at least one of whom was from the Toronto force — about the legal justification for the measures being taken around the perimeter. Neither breathed a word about anything about the Public Works Protection Act, let alone any recent cabinet decisions that affected it."

“It’s just unbelievable you would have this kind of abuse of power where the cabinet can create this offense without having it debated in the legislature,” Vasey's lawyer, Howard Morton, told the Star.

Activist groups say that keeping the new police powers a secret means they have been giving G20 protesters inaccurate advice about how to deal with police confrontations. Vasey himself refused to show identification to police because he was following the advice laid out by the Toronto Community Mobilization Network, which is organizing some G20 protest activities.

"This act values public property over the freedom of people and prevents community members from walking freely through the streets without questioning from authorities," the group said on its Web site Friday. "We will not be made examples of, but rather, we will publicly denounce oppressive activities of the state and highlight the solidarity in our communities."

Vasey is scheduled to appear in court on July 28.

ADVERTISEMENT
  • C.P.T.L.
    Let me get this straight:

    Not only did Canada make a primary historical blunder - and the limits and the sunset clause don't mitigate the blunder; it's the precedent that matters - a thing so retrograde as to bump a civil society back to a totalitarianism or fascism...

    ...but with a functioning government and legal system presumably operated by the 'brighter bulbs' of the country, they could not come up with anything better than 'double secret probation' straight out of the Animal House movie?
  • Schmice
    Some Americans believe that when things get really bad here they'll just move to Canada where they will live free from oppression. I knew that Canada was backwards in some ways but never figured that they were so backwards that it's 1984 over there.
  • walkertee
    How can you Canadians make a law like that in secret? Who do you think you are? Americams?
  • starvapor
    “It’s just unbelievable you would have this kind of abuse of power where the cabinet can create this offense without having it debated in the legislature,”...

    This is abuse of power purchased by the wealthy, solely for the protection of the wealthy. You or I would never have such protection established for us.
  • EndCurrencyMonopoly
    If you were stealing trillions of dollars from common people, you'd want all the security you could muster, no?

    These kind folks print money from thin air, then charge you, your government, and everyone else 'interest' for the right to use that money. These are the most profitable corporations on planet earth, and yet few recognize them as such.

    Everyone can recognize the greed-- and the evil that springs forth-- of a giant oil company like BP, but most remain in the dark about Central Banks and their private owners.

    There is more debt than can ever be repaid, thanks to the design of the monetary system these folks profit from. It is intentional that you should live your entire lives in debt slavery, and that they unduly reap the rewards of your labor. Your standard of living will go down, taxes will rise-- in perpetuity-- to serve, and maintain this regime.
  • canadaeh
    Well!
    Please United States don’t start a war with Canada to bring us democracy we are doing fine up here with out you.
  • sanchosdad
    sure sounds like the bush administration to me. is john yoo up there? how about bybee? perle? wolfowit z? i KNOW that alberto gonzalez is unemployed.
  • This what Canada gets for letting their leadership be infiltrated by neo-con lobbyists and sympathizers. Kiss those freedoms goodbye, Canucks...welcome to globalist hell like the rest of us.
  • BroccoliRob
    Gee, I wonder why those Canadians would do such a thing? I guess they are jus afraid of democracy. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgPWg25R_Xc&feat...
  • BroccoliRob
    If you need any further proof than the negative effects of Global Warming, we need to look no futher than to see the effect of extreme overheating upon Al Gore. Like all good democrats, he left his "fingerprints" on this issue. What diabolical climatoloigical extreme caused Tipper to suspend drilling, causing Al to explore further and futher in more perilous waters off-shore? Sooner or later, it was inevitable for there to be spillage and now we are left with the prospect of a very messy cleanup.
  • mschlee
    FREE CANADA

    DIRECT DEMOCRACY
  • noidrequired
    Protesters need to start carrying guns, and when the police demand identification shoot them first and ask questions later. Only that will keep the police in line.
  • jimthebeam
    Why don't they just pray that there is no protest?
  • NapalmGod
    Y'know, one would think that any judge, no matter the nationality, would throw out cases brought under "secret" laws where the person arrested had no conceivable means of knowing that the act was against the law.
  • BroccoliRob
    Double Secret probation!"
  • The only thing missing in some western counties, are the brown shirted goose stepping troops.
  • starvapor
    Please...don't encourage them any further.
  • BroccoliRob
    Yes, we already have the crazy anarchists!
  • Our good neighbors to the north will preserve their sacred image of Scandinavian sterility at all costs. Beware: Dudley Doorite will go straight medieval on your smarty pants iznass.
  • Hmmm, not so "secret" now are they.
  • The Central Bankers from around the world are meeting to discus the continuance of the cooperation that enables the mechanism which has made it so that we now work 100 hrs a week per household -- until we are 80 years old,. . . . before we are maybe lucky enough to retire.

    These are the representatives of the very owners of the 'money' itself. They are the emissaries of the death merchants and warmakers. They are not your enemy per se, but they will do in a pinch.
  • MacD7586
    Members from the Zeitgeist Movement will be there in force distributing DVD's Having discussions with protesters and giving out FREE Hugs
  • markusgarvey
    In an effort to serve the online community best, please verify your account so that your comments will post as soon as they are posted in the future. Thanks
  • Timeforchanges
    Hitler would be Proud
  • Hitler failed. These pricks didn't.
  • markusgarvey
    In an effort to serve the online community best, please verify your account so that your comments will post as soon as they are posted in the future. Thanks
  • markusgarvey
    In an effort to serve the online community best, please verify your account so that your comments will post as soon as they are posted in the future. Thanks
  • QuadSlacker
    A report released this week by the Parliamentary Budget Office says the two summits are expected to cost Canadians C$930 million (US$893 million) in security alone, including more than C$500 million for the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Together with other hosting costs — including nearly C$2 million for a marketing and media pavilion in Toronto that includes a "fake lake" — the total tab will run well north of C$1 billion.

    "There's a nagging sense police, public servants and politicians are wallowing in a bottomless trough they figure Canadians will constantly replenish, columnist James Travers wrote in the Toronto Star, the country's biggest newspaper.

    Nagging? More like common. But quite right.
  • RadicalCaveman
    In this case, ignorance of the law IS a defense.
  • farang
    Reminds me of the "secret" law in Laos that says you will be arrested if you have intimate relations with a foreign national.

    If it is secret, how the hell can you obey it?

    O Canada....how's it feel to have your PM fellate Bennie Nuttyahoo while his pirates murdered Peace activists?

    Now, they are coming for YOU! And YOU will pay for it, chumpskies.....
  • BroccoliRob
    "Peace Activists" I guess we did not need to look at their "rap sheets" did we?
  • Richie73
    This just proves again that modern "democracy" is a farce. A theater play produced for us commoners by the elites. When push comes to shove, they show their true face, and all that pretense of due process and freedom goes out the window.

    When our political and economic elites speak of freedom, they mean THEIR freedom. Freedom to exploit, profit and control this planet and its populations.
  • BroccoliRob
    Yes, lets have some good old-fashioned violently rabid anarchy. How else can we preserve democracy? I am assuming you have seen the pevious G-8 protests. I think that we should aways have the G-8 in the model enlightened socialist countries like China, Russia, Cuba or North Korea. Those governments will insure that the protesters are treated in an understanding and nuanced liberal way.
  • donofcali
    The global plutocrats are getting worried. Their security is getting tighter. In a few years, unless they're stopped, these areas will end up being free-fire zones.

    To the "guards": How does it feel to be a traitor to the People? How do you like serving the Plutocracy? The world will be a much better place if you learn the Truth and redirect your weapons towards our true enemy.
  • johnniefavorite
    You know what, you are god damm right.
    Why the fuck would somebody take some job making what, 40-50 grand a year to beat and fuck with their fellow citizens. You know I hope they have fun rotting in hell with their masters.
  • BroccoliRob
    I don' know. The anarchists are doing it for free!
  • Our 'beat cops' make well north of 100K when you include the detail work. Some are making 200K in a city that has 1 murder a year. . . and that happens in an area that they don't bother 'policing'. If it gets hairy, you can bet your guys will be getting more from the 'trough'.
  • captainfrank
    Time to figure out how you feed the beast. If you really want change you might want to cease your support.
  • That support is collected at gunpoint.
  • scytherius
    We need to just overthrow the World.
  • BroccoliRob
    I think you are on to something here.
  • parrots_abound
    Welcome to tyranny Canada.....enjoy.
  • enorceht
    this is really puke worthy
  • conspiraseer
    Check out We Are Change dott org for a video of 2 activists denied entry into Canada.
blog comments powered by Disqus