NidalHasan
Martyrdom in Islam Versus Suicide Bombing
from rizkhan999 in Research, Humanities
from www.salafimanhaj.com
seangleeson:
NidalHasan: Just wondering, are you the same Nidal Hasan who murdered American soldiers at Fort Hood on Nov. 5, 2009?
yousefalkhattab:
Just goes to show, salafimanhajCOM radicalized this brother.
patnone:
@Seangleeson....yeah I'm sure as soon as he gets out of the hospital, he'll head straight to the nearest computer to log on to Scribd.com to respond to your question from a post that is over a year old.
Idiot.
2LT JB:
You are a disgrace to the United States Military.
octanefiveseven:
like most disgusting officers
seangleeson:
@patnone: No, I was specifically wondering if this were a DIFFERENT NidalHasan. You see? (And the post is not "over a year old" anyway.)
@NidaIHasan: Clever. But of course you switched a capital I for a lower case L. I just thought I would point it out for the benefit of people who didn't notice your little joke.
digitaltrix:
I don't know who you are and it's obvious you're not the military personnel currently in custody being allowed access to Scribd but I have one thing to say:
digitaltrix:
Islam is a religion for all times and is nothing new in this world, it attracts it's followers due to a theology based around civil order, submission and accountability and peace unto oneself and others.
It saddens me deeply that you would put such information online and try and project what you have learned or hypothesized as anything relating to Islam.
digitaltrix:
You mention 'scholars' in your opinion but unfortunately you do not even quote one known scholar. Anyone who commits such a heinous act and takes even the body of one living animal let alone a human is deeply misled and will never be given peace in this life and beyond. Even during the time of Islam's spread when wars took place there were certain rules of engagement and due rights to POWs.
digitaltrix:
How dare you march in here trying to blend your unique thoughts with such a great religion and the words of something that is beyond your comprehension. I advise you if you are truly Muslim to seek mental help FIRST & then the Quraan and you will find peace IA. Stop this propaganda it is shameful for the world community.
sunira-chaudhri-500:
a horrible, unfortunate event. don't drag religion into this - or read more meaning into this post then necessary. It just contributes to speculation and the propaganda that the media thrives on.
maryjolos:
Not all Muslims are terrorists but all terrorists are Muslims.
titan2270:
Just out of curiosity, how is the news reporting that this "Nidal Hasan" is the same guy in custody? I just googled the name, and found a Nidal Hasan who is a Dr in Chicago and so forth. There are thirteen "Nidal Hasan" 's in the US listed on a public records site and so forth. Shoddy reporting from the major outlets if you ask me.
Lovejoy0303:
They didn't say this IS the same guy. They said that 6 months ago they were looking into the possibility of it. No offical investigation was conducted because there was no evidence to prove it.
benjaminwatson79:
I just see too many spelling errors in that passage. Do you really believe an MD officer would write so poorly? This seems like somebody who just got a GED.
southbvirus:
This is creepy... this was posted in May. So that makes me believe this is the actual Nidal, yet; there is a Nidal posting here, same name - but there is no way the actual one could be....
southbvirus:
That the same Nidal is currently posting*
John Sawyer:
No, as seangleeson points out above, the person who seems to be currently posting as "NidalHasan", is actually posting as "NidaIHasan", where what appears to be a lower case "L", is actually a capital "i". Otherwise known as a "creep".
blu_yin:
I just wish, that whether it is the same person or not, that we not jump to conclusions. We don't know why. We don't know anything. Just because he is a Muslim American, doesn't mean he is a terrorist. We have plenty of American terrorists right here killing our own children, babies and women and I never see the same outrage, the same out cry for justice or 6 hr news coverage
2OP HG:
This is obviously him, and he obviously planned this attack inline with his blog entry.
As evidence, you only need this line of he wrote:
" If one suicide bomber can kill 100 enemy soldiers because they were caught off guard that would be considered a strategic victory"
He tried to kill 100 soldiers, he caught them off guard, and he felt it was a strategic victory for Islam.
Period.
blu_yin:
Secondly, if this NidalHasan is the same as the person at Ft. Hood, these comments listed here alone and in this context do not, IMO, represent the comments of a terrorist. If you read the article and the response, you will see that he is discussing what defines a suicide bomber v. what would be considered an act of heroism.
blu_yin:
2OP HG: I believe you are taking the comment out of context. First let me say that I don't support any person that takes the life of another innocent person, however, we don't know anything about how he felt or what he thought. For hrs we were told he was dead to learn he was alive, I find at this moment it is hard to KNOW anything.
blu_yin:
He did go on to say that Japanese Kamikaze's who bombed the US & killed innocent people- killing what they believed to be the enemy, for their homeland. Should we now assume all Japanese are terrorists too? How about any caucasian, who has roots to the Nazis, are they also terrorists? what of the man where we have just found 11 women dead in his home, isn't he a terrorist by the same definition?
blu_yin:
LOVEJOY: CNN did in fact say this is the same guy! They showed this post on TV and said that HE posted this response. That the government was looking at him based on THESE and other posts. They also said this was HIS blog. It is not his blog. He posted a response to an article. Our media reports whats easy, whats expected, what gets viewers not necessarily whats accurate.
2OP HG:
blu_yin: you're missing the point. He isn't discussing suicide bombing vs. heroism, he's EQUATING the two. Grenade jumper = Suicide Bomber = Shooting unarmed soliders in TX = Saving lives = HERO. Open your eyes, he thinks he's saving muslim lives by killing American soldiers, and he considers himself a Islamic hero. He says as much.
matthew-rose-1645:
The man doesn't value life. He thought he was doing something right. He is a "terrorist". Soldiers kill innocent people all the time. This reminds me of a clip I saw on yahoo where a guy tackled his teammate.
blu_yin:
I have to respectfully disagree and urge you to look at it again. If an American soldier kills hundreds of muslims by dropping a bomb on them while they're not prepared, is that not a strategic victory as well? Why is it only terrorism if the word Muslim is present? We killed 100's of muslim soldiers, that we thought enemies. Why are the only terrorists we see the ones with arabic names?
blu_yin:
2OP: I have to respectfully, disagree, I won't try to convince you, but urge you to re-read the passage. He is simply explaining his POV on whats defined as a suicide. This is not about a suicide bomber, muslim or otherwise. It was using Muslims, Japanese and an American soldier as an example. Saying none of these acts should be considered suicide in a negative way.
blu_yin:
2OP: IMO; He is simply explaining his POV on whats defined as a suicide. This is not about a suicide bomber, muslim or otherwise. It was using Muslims, Japanese and an American soldier as an example. Saying none of these acts should be considered suicide in a negative way.
Artificial_Stupidity:
seangleeson: this post has been attributed to him as reported by Nightline. Though it's somewhat ridiculous to try asking him if he was the one who did the shooting, 1) he's in the hospital 2) he's under arrest and 3) do you honestly think anyone would answer that question if they were??
obamalied:
You are a f'ing moron. Sacrificing your own life to make sure no one else is killed is not the same as some murderous heathen Muslim bloodlust idiot who kills himself to make sure others are killed. You give Islam a bad name. Any muslim that doesn't immediately denounce your blood lusting violent murderous throughts is a freak and a heathen. You are stained with pigs blood. Pigs blood upon you
obamalied:
When will this world stop being so cowardly and quit being afraid to denigrate Islam like it denigrates other religions? In the new movie 2012, the vatican is destroyed, so is the sistine chapel, but the Kabaa isn't touched. Hollywood, cartoonists, 'artists' are afraid of Islam...cowards! Id LOVE to see a movie that destroys the Kabaa and shows Mohammad getting his ass kicked! Id pay for that
obamalied:
You murdered people in Texas. This isn't a state full of leftist liberals. The socialist democrat liberal will want to "listen' to you and give you lots of 'therapy" and try to "understand" you. Texas will fry your ass. I'm glad you survived, now you can face justice you fuck. Texas will show no mercy to your heathen ass.
SOCLIB:
This is one socialist liberal who is against the death penalty but wouldn't be too exercised about Nidal's fate either way. But Obamalied definitely needs therapy.
Antiterror:
May God bless you Dr.nidal... you deserve much accolade for your brave act of sending murderers and rapists back to hell.. the american army which has destroyed hundreds of nations,murdered over a million people in the last decade,raped and bombed should be destroyed for the greater good of humanity
Antiterror:
The fact that he was a psychiatrist and had to listen to all those horrible stories of murder and rampage by the soldiers must have totally freaked him out and he took this bold step on behalf of millions of people of iraq,afghanistan,vietnam,cuba etc who are awaiting revenge and justice.Thanks for bringing back the chickens home to roost Nidal.May God bless you
AllahGoatFucker:
Hey Antiterror you sorry piece of shit, your martyr lived, and he was shot by a woman...how's that for a fucking insult to Islam you fag? ALLAH Suck my COCKBAR BITCH!
jdgilk:
Murder vs killing in war are two totally different things. In war you follow certain rules set up by civilized societies and is done to protect your civilian population from an enemy who has attacked or has shown a tendency to attack. Murder you hide your weapon, dont make your intentions known, dont follow international law, and hide in the shadows. Cowards practice murder. Heros engage in war.
+ See more activity