Digital Publisher of the Year | Sunday 01 November 2009 | UK News feed

Advertisement

'Racism' claim over mean Scots used in German adverts

German companies have been accused of racial abuse by using the phrase Schotten Preise, meaning Scottish prices, to advertise discounted goods.

 

The Scottish National Party is to lodge an official complaint with Germany’s advertising association, arguing the long-established marketing technique is offensive.

Angus Robertson MP, the party’s Westminster leader, said the phrase promotes an unfair racial stereotype that Scots are mean and advertisers would not dare make the same association with orthodox Jews.

‘Schotten Preise’ is used in Germany to market products ranging from fast food to low-cost holidays, while the names of many discount stores contain the prefix “Mac”.

Mr Robertson, the son of a German, said it was unacceptable to portray Scots in such a pejorative way. “It doesn’t have to be this way,” he argued.

“You wouldn’t do it with orthodox Jews, so why do it with Scots? The constant association of our country and people with meanness and cheapness is beginning to hit at the borders of defamation and insult.”

“Schotten Preise” may derive from the 15th century when many Scots lived in German-populated areas of the Baltic and are believed to have offered goods at competitive prices.

David McAllister, leader of Germany's governing Christian Democratic Union party, who is of Scottish descent, warned it would take years before Germans dispense with the stereotype of Scots as skinflints.

He said: “Germans are generally careful not to employ national stereotypes. But there seems to be one nation exempt from that, and that's Scotland.”

Geizkragen, one of the country's most popular price-comparison websites, uses adverts featuring a Scot wearing a kilt and tartan hat chasing coins and advising Germans how to save money.

Travel agents regularly advertise “Schotten Preise” for bargains and last year the ADAC, a German motoring club, sent an email to 15 million customers featuring a kilt-wearing Scot pushing his car to save petrol.

Oliver Flaskamper, who founded Geizkragen, said the mean Scot on his website was intended to be endearing.

He said: “We have never had any complaints, even though we are near a British army base with a lot of Scottish soldiers.”

Alex Johnstone, a Conservative MSP, accused Mr Robertson of indulging in “a kind of political correctness we could well do without”, saying he should act “in a more light-hearted and engaged way”.

Last year a Scottish cultural society in Hungary complained about Burger King launching a “Scottish menu”, arguing it portrayed Scots in a poor light.

In 2002, Kenny MacAskill, who is now Scotland’s justice minister, branded a Ford campaign in Austria as racist.

The advert showed a mechanic opening a bonnet, at which point bagpipe music started playing. A voice-over then stated: “Experience the saving potential of the new Ford engine.”

 
 
London Freeze ski festival
Worst sports kits
weirdest 2010 calendars
Indian state visit
Advertisement
Advertisement

It's a wonderful, mixed-up world

more mixed-race children than ever before

There are now more mixed-race children than ever - and that is something to celebate, says scientist Aarathi Prasad.

News Most Viewed

Sponsored Features

BT's Next Generation Access

Next Generation Access from BT will allow everyone to benefit from fast internet connections.

Photo competition

Enter your favourite pet photos for your chance to win some fantastic prizes.

Free brochures and test drives

Test drive the latest Citroën cars, including the C3 Picasso, now available under the Citroen Scrappage Scheme.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

World in Motion

Digital Camera Photographer of the Year 2009: World in Motion - editor's choice shortlist

Photographer of the Year 2009: shortlisted World in Motion photos.

The week in pictures

A round-up of our favourite photographs of the week.

Sport's worst kits

In pics: England's purple players are not the only offenders.

TELEGRAPH DATING

PracticalCat_770

Hi. I'm Mike , I'm a photographer and guitarist from the tiny village of Ashurst in West Sussex - in fact, if you blink, you'll probably miss it. I keep company with horses,...