Costco sells a lot -- but not this particular doll
Filed under: Shopping
The news is getting old now, but the controversy continues to be discussed throughout cyberspace, in newspapers and numerous web sites, including Snopes: earlier this month, Costco Wholesale Corp. pulled from their stores African-American dolls that were deemed to be racially insensitive.
And for understandable reasons. These African-American baby dolls, called "Cuddle with Me," were packaged with stuffed monkeys and wearing a hat that read, "Lil' Monkey."
Recently, a Boston policeman made news for calling a prominent African-American Harvard professor a "banana-eating jungle monkey." It's an ugly racial slur that is, unfortunately, still going strong in certain circles.
Anyway, in this case, it seems like it was just a matter of not thinking things through, than anyone intending to offend people. There were other versions of the doll with the "Lil Monkey" hat, including a Caucasian version, and certainly many parents have referred to their young, climbing, crazy little kids as monkeys.
To its credit, Costco pulled the offending item off the shelves as soon as a customer complained. A vice president later made the statement that the store takes full responsibility for putting the dolls on the shelves, and he said that he has "expressed our regrets that this did have the tendency to offend some folks."
The CEO, Mary Gustaff, of the company that made the dolls put it even better, saying to the press: "It's so unfortunate because now it's being portrayed as a purposeful act to be disrespectful and that's not true. We really apologize. We don't think in that way. We don't operate in that kind of thinking. We really have a diverse family-operated company that's been around for 28 years. What would we have to gain for heaven's sake?"
Indeed. What would they have to gain? Maybe it's a sign of the times, a good sign, that so many people in the process of getting this doll on shelves -- from the toy designer to the person stocking the shelves -- didn't notice that the doll could be taken as a racial insult? As in, they never use the slur, never think about the slur, didn't notice that it could be taken that way? At least, that's my hope. But the store did the right thing in taking the toy down so quickly. The last thing one needs is a bunch of racists -- and we know they're out there -- buying these dolls and somehow using them to spread their message of hate.
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,entry&id=580896&pid=580895&uts=1251407801
http://cdn.channel.aol.com/cs_feed_v1_6/csfeedwrapper.swf
Can They Really Do That?
Crazy times call for crazy measures, but not where your financial security is concerned. Click through our gallery of "Can They Really Do That?" money stories.
Getty Images
AP
WalletPop is not responsible for caption content.
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 14)
8-28-2009 @ 7:23AM
cassie said...
people only get offended if something is the truth...
Reply
8-28-2009 @ 8:59AM
heidi said...
cassie- your absolutely right great comment
8-28-2009 @ 9:22AM
STEVE said...
how is that racist?? there were white dolls with the same hat and monkey?????
8-28-2009 @ 9:22AM
ceil827 said...
Glad they took the doll off. I found somthing at Costco that is even cheaper on line. Its a plant you can grow that moves like an animal. It is a TickleMe Plant and it closes its leaves and lowers its branches when tickled. My students rush to class to tickle their Pet Plants. Just search The TickleMe Plant to get your own little greenhouse to grow one
8-28-2009 @ 10:19AM
JB said...
That is ridiculously untrue--AND offensive. People get offended when something is not true as well as when it is, if the intention (or damaging amount of ignorance, if the intention isn't there) behind the offending act belittles or invalidates them. It's the tendency of a portrayal to marginalize or dehumanize the type of person portrayed that is the issue here.
Whether or not the doll is offensive, the fact that what it portrays is true or untrue has NOTHING to do with why someone would be offended by it.
8-28-2009 @ 10:30AM
boots66 said...
So, Cassie, does that mean you will be offended if I call you a d0uche?
8-28-2009 @ 11:00AM
lsteve10007 said...
No one has even mentioned the fact the picture attached looks like village of the damned lol If all of the dolls had the same shirt and hats then I think people are over reacting. People now a days are getting so thin skinned it's unreal... look what England is doing with their vocabulary, sad sad.
8-28-2009 @ 11:46AM
lcino said...
This is crap. Before long we will have to revert back to the generic dolls. Racism is bad. Should I start to sue Chris Rock because he says that there are some "Cracka's" in the audience tonight. Comedians will be next on the list. We will not be able to say or do anything in the future. People need to live there lives and not worry so much about what other people are doing. If someone wants to purchase the doll or not, just do so and stop bitchin' about every little thing.
8-28-2009 @ 12:11PM
FraeFrae said...
You are right.....and the truth is that it {monkey} has been used as a slur and continues to be used.
8-28-2009 @ 12:40PM
dejeve said...
i laugh because black people refer to themselves as monkeys and niggaz all the time. Black people by far are more racist than most white people yet white people bend over backwards because at a young age they are taught to feel guilt for something that most of them had no part in (Blame the corrupt school system and the liberal teachers). Black people on the other hand are raised to feed off of that guilt and use it to their advantage. White people need to realise that black people (not all) are using that against white people. but both black people and white people need to realise that there are more than 2 races in this world.
WHITE PEOPLE WAKE THE FVCK UP!
still don't believe me? youtube: "LOUIS FARRAKHAN: White Folks, You Owe Us The Whole Country!"
and then see what i'm talking about.....
8-28-2009 @ 1:16PM
kalifani6 said...
The only truth is you are the monkey you racist ape.
8-28-2009 @ 1:14PM
dj1075696683dd44 said...
8650c46f
I had no interest in watching the news at present....I found a hot place, you guys should try it
----- S e e k a M i l l i o n a i re . C om---It 's where you have the opportunity dreaming about dating a millionaire and make it true!
8-28-2009 @ 1:44PM
Whtt Crap said...
We should have left the negroes in the African jungles with all the other monkeys. It's our own fault for bringing them into our great country. We should have picked our own cotton.
8-28-2009 @ 2:43PM
Terri said...
I am black, and I wasn't offended by the doll when I first saw it months ago, because I don't see myself as inferior to people of any race, and obviously because there were also white dolls of the same variety. But just because something is offensive, doesn't mean it's true. Self-esteem and self-image may alter your perception of yourself, but you aren't always what you think you are, for better OR for worse. You might have an athletic, muscular build, but if you're offended when someone calls you fat, it doesn't mean that you are. And yet, that three letter word is somehow powerful enough to send scores of housewives, teenagers, and celebrities in paroxysms of despair.
8-28-2009 @ 4:24PM
TexAngel4561 said...
I encourage you to check out photos of these dolls to get the full impact that the woman in this story got. It would have been more conducive to understanding had Geoff Williams posted actual photos of these dolls. Perhaps then everyone would understand that there is merit to the woman's complaint. At the very least, this company should have mixed the various stuffed animals with the different racial types represented by the babies; this may, in fact, be the case. (Since i have not seen examples of the other babies, i cannot say for sure one way or the other.)
When seen in the best light, there is (at the very least) an unconcious racial bias in the choice of the monkey and the words "lil monkey" for the little black baby doll and a panda and the words "pretty panda" for the white baby. Also, the words, "Monkey has her own bottle," is inflamatory for no other reason that its double entendre, especially given the banana-eating-monkey comments spewed about by certain unenlightened people.
Racial bias DOES exist in our country. And it is important for those who do not go to the extreme of racism to understand that. And through that understanding a certain amount of compassion can be found for those who suffer under its weight.
At the same time it is important to realize that people of all races have suffered the sting of racial prejudice. No ONE RACE has a monopoly on being the victim of racism. Hate comes in many colors.
Also, it is important to acknowledge those of other races that choose NOT to participate in racism. For it is not blacks that are racist and neither is it the whites that are racists. Racists are the ones who are racist.
And the solution in the end is to see all people as being worthy of our respect regardless of their color.
PAX
8-28-2009 @ 4:26PM
Inkling said...
Unless someone actually thinks they are a monkey why should a doll offend them? What is stupid is that ALL the dolls regardless of color came with the monkey and hat. It seems that black people want to own everything, nooses, the word monkey, the animal monkey, the word negro, the word ghetto, the word slavery, etc. Many people have been slaves in this country, have been hung by a noose, and have lived in ghettos, and they weren't all black or male. The word "negro" isn't even an English word. It is a bunch of hooey.
8-28-2009 @ 7:52AM
Al said...
Give me a break!!! We have become so sensitive that every liteel things sets people off. And COSTCO removes a product from the shelves because ONE person complains?
The writer of this article is just as bad. Racists buying the doll to spread their message of hate?
Racism is bad. Period. But this doll does not spread that message and bothy the customer andthe author need to lighten up and find something really important to complain about.
Reply
8-28-2009 @ 9:49AM
Kip said...
Oddly enough, I think you missed the sarcasm there, Al. Anyhow, my generation didn't even know about that slur until the police officer used it.
What irks me is all of these people out there just waiting to get offended by something as stupid and as simple as a baby doll.
I'm sorry that some people's great-grandparents were ignorant and fearful enough to use slurs and try to restrict african-americans. I'm also NOT sorry that that time is over, and has been over.
I personally don't walk around and listen to make sure that every person that's different from me respects me and my culture. Not only is that exhausting, time consuming and silly, all you have to do is watch BET. You want racial slurs, comments and stereotypes? Seriously. Tune in. And until you do, don't whine about a cute, cuddly baby doll that comes in 'monkey' for all races.
8-28-2009 @ 11:22AM
Andy V said...
You're both absolutely right and you don't have to go as far as BET to see the hypocrisy and reverse racism. Just click on AOL's own Black Voices! Hmmm...could you imagine if we had White Voices? The world would be up in arms or at least pretend to me as not to offend the people of color.
8-28-2009 @ 8:13AM
Joe said...
Sarah,
I don't know how old you are, but the whole "monkey" thing is pretty old. Calling an African American "monkey" has been a racial slur for the longest time.
Reply