Dave Mustaine No.1 in Joel McIvers 100 M ...
The Off-Topic board is a place for you to gather and chatter about anything 'other' than video games! We expect everyone to follow these guidelines along with the Terms Of Use agreement. If you find abuse that does not follow this agreement or the additional guidelines please report the content as abuse. Important! Posting in an account suicide thread can result in a moderation with a possible suspension on your account. Reminder: It is required that you read the rules specific to this board.
UPDATE: Newly revised religious topic guidelines must be followed in this board.- Apr 22, 2009 5:42 pm PT
http://www.amazon.com/100-Greatest-Metal-Guitarists/dp/1906002207/
here are the top 20 ( LOL @ 20 and 19 )
remember this isnt based soely on technical skill, its based on impact, influence, technique, different things they play, how much they contribute to their band, and technical skill.. so.. pretty much the overall person. ( if it were just technical skill, Iommi wouldnt even be on the top 100)
20. Herman Li
19. Mick Thompson (that's right, the guy from Slipknot.)
18. Kerry King
17. Ihsahn
16. Tom Morello
15. Kirk Hammett
14. Ralph Santolla
13. Alex Skolnick
12. Pat O'Brien
11. Fredrik Thordendal
10. Chuck Schuldiner
9. Mikael Akerfeldt
8. James Hetfield
7. Trey Azagthoth
6. Tony Iommi
5. Dimebag Darrell
4. Zakk Wylde
3. Jeff Waters
2. John Petrucci
1. Dave MustaineMEGADAVE 4 LYFE
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:45 pm PTHow exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course)
And I'm glad Petrucci scored that high, although I would put him firstHow exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course) And I'm glad Petrucci scored that high, although I would put him first :P- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:47 pm PTLuncbox1 wrote:How exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course) And I'm glad Petrucci scored that high, although I would put him first
probly because james writes the lyrics, sings and plays.. and he's actually a better player than kirk.. also james most of the time tells kirk what to play, kirk complained about this on some kind of monster, saying he really has no say on what he gets to add, pretty much all kirk does get to do is make up a solo for a specific time slot... james and lars forced him to use mustaine's solo's for the songs on kill em all and RTL... so yeah... james is the real backbone of metallica.. kirk is the hired gun lead player.[QUOTE="Luncbox1"]How exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course) And I'm glad Petrucci scored that high, although I would put him first :P[/QUOTE] probly because james writes the lyrics, sings and plays.. and he's actually a better player than kirk.. also james most of the time tells kirk what to play, kirk complained about this on some kind of monster, saying he really has no say on what he gets to add, pretty much all kirk does get to do is make up a solo for a specific time slot... james and lars forced him to use mustaine's solo's for the songs on kill em all and RTL... so yeah... james is the real backbone of metallica.. kirk is the hired gun lead player.- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:49 pm PTnimatoad2000 wrote:Luncbox1 wrote:How exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course) And I'm glad Petrucci scored that high, although I would put him first
probly because james writes the lyrics, sings and plays.. and he's actually a better player than kirk.. also james most of the time tells kirk what to play, kirk complained about this on some kind of monster, saying he really has no say on what he gets to add, pretty much all kirk does get to do is make up a solo for a specific time slot... james and lars forced him to use mustaine's solo's for the songs on kill em all and RTL... so yeah... james is the real backbone of metallica.. kirk is the hired gun lead player.
oh. Okay, I guess that makes sense then. I was never big enough into that band to know that. Forgive my ignorance.[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"][QUOTE="Luncbox1"]How exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course) And I'm glad Petrucci scored that high, although I would put him first :P[/QUOTE] probly because james writes the lyrics, sings and plays.. and he's actually a better player than kirk.. also james most of the time tells kirk what to play, kirk complained about this on some kind of monster, saying he really has no say on what he gets to add, pretty much all kirk does get to do is make up a solo for a specific time slot... james and lars forced him to use mustaine's solo's for the songs on kill em all and RTL... so yeah... james is the real backbone of metallica.. kirk is the hired gun lead player. [/QUOTE] oh. Okay, I guess that makes sense then. I was never big enough into that band to know that. Forgive my ignorance. :P- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:49 pm PTI say the sameLuncbox1 wrote:How exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course)
Dave Mustaine and Megadeth rocks
[QUOTE="Luncbox1"]How exactly did Kirk Hammet score lower than James Hetfield? Hammet plays lead guitar and Hetfield plays rhythm (as a general rule, of course) :P[/QUOTE]I say the same
Dave Mustaine and Megadeth rocks:D
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:50 pm PTWTF......No Jari Maenpaa, Muhammed Suicmez, or Jeff Loomis in the top 2?!
And Hammet is lower then Hetfeild?! WTH....
WTF......No Jari Maenpaa, Muhammed Suicmez, or Jeff Loomis in the top 2?!:x And Hammet is lower then Hetfeild?! WTH....- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:52 pm PTguys hetfield is better than hammet. not to mention hetfield contributes soo much more to metallica..
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:53 pm PT
Michael Angelo, Joe Stump, Steve Vai, Malsteem?
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:54 pm PTDarth-Caedus wrote:WTF......No Jari Maenpaa, Muhammed Suicmez, or Jeff Loomis in the top 2?!
i doubt suicmez would be high up darth, this isnt a 100 best technically skilled guitar players list, necrophagist isnt really popular... read what i said on the main post. as i said, if it was technically skilled, Iommi wouldnt even be int he book.
[QUOTE="Darth-Caedus"]WTF......No Jari Maenpaa, Muhammed Suicmez, or Jeff Loomis in the top 2?!:x And Hammet is lower then Hetfeild?! WTH.... [/QUOTE]
i doubt suicmez would be high up darth, this isnt a 100 best technically skilled guitar players list, necrophagist isnt really popular... read what i said on the main post. as i said, if it was technically skilled, Iommi wouldnt even be int he book.
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:54 pm PTI find it pretty dumb how Alexi Laiho isn't on there while Kerry King is.I find it pretty dumb how Alexi Laiho isn't on there while Kerry King is. :?
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:57 pm PTnimatoad2000 wrote:Darth-Caedus wrote:WTF......No Jari Maenpaa, Muhammed Suicmez, or Jeff Loomis in the top 2?!
i doubt suicmez would be high up darth, this isnt a 100 best technically skilled guitar players list, necrophagist isnt really popular... read what i said on the main post. as i said, if it was technically skilled, Iommi wouldnt even be int he book.
Oh, skiped over that part of your post >.>[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"][QUOTE="Darth-Caedus"]WTF......No Jari Maenpaa, Muhammed Suicmez, or Jeff Loomis in the top 2?!:x And Hammet is lower then Hetfeild?! WTH.... [/QUOTE]
i doubt suicmez would be high up darth, this isnt a 100 best technically skilled guitar players list, necrophagist isnt really popular... read what i said on the main post. as i said, if it was technically skilled, Iommi wouldnt even be int he book.
[/QUOTE] Oh, skiped over that part of your post >.> :P- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:58 pm PT
Sounds about right... Dave Mustaine is one of the most devoted guys to his band I've ever seen.He writes all the songs, he sings while playing some killer riffs, and he can dish out a mean solo too.Plus, not many people could get kicked out and deserted by their best friends, far far away from home and get over it the way he did.
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 5:58 pm PTnimatoad2000 wrote:
20. Herman Li
[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"]
20. Herman Li
[/QUOTE]
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:02 pm PT[QUOTE="BeepBoop16"]
[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"]
20. Herman Li
[/QUOTE]
stupid picture QUOTE] its not my list dude, so dont be posting your facepalm pix here, its the top 20 list from a BOOK.. if your upset about the list.. email the guy.- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:04 pm PT
[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"][QUOTE="BeepBoop16"]
[QUOTE="nimatoad2000"]
20. Herman Li
[/QUOTE]
stupid picture QUOTE] its not my list dude, so dont be posting your facepalm pix here, its the top 20 list from a BOOK.. if your upset about the list.. email the guy.[/QUOTE]
No, I won't email him. I will facepalm his list. It will hurt him more that way.
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:04 pm PTHerman Li shouldn't be in that list. He's terribly sloppy.
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:05 pm PT[QUOTE="-Misanthropic-"]
Sounds about right... Dave Mustaine is one of the most devoted guys to his band I've ever seen.He writes all the songs, he sings while playing some killer riffs, and he can dish out a mean solo too.Plus, not many people could get kicked out and deserted by their best friends, far far away from home and get over it the way he did.
[/QUOTE] Get over it? He complains about it plenty.- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:07 pm PTLuncbox1 wrote:Get over it? He complains about it plenty.-Misanthropic- wrote:
Sounds about right... Dave Mustaine is one of the most devoted guys to his band I've ever seen.He writes all the songs, he sings while playing some killer riffs, and he can dish out a mean solo too.Plus, not many people could get kicked out and deserted by their best friends, far far away from home and get over it the way he did.
What else could he say when in every single interview he ever done, the subject of his ejection from Metallica came up?
[QUOTE="Luncbox1"][QUOTE="-Misanthropic-"]
Sounds about right... Dave Mustaine is one of the most devoted guys to his band I've ever seen.He writes all the songs, he sings while playing some killer riffs, and he can dish out a mean solo too.Plus, not many people could get kicked out and deserted by their best friends, far far away from home and get over it the way he did.
[/QUOTE] Get over it? He complains about it plenty. [/QUOTE]
What else could he say when in every single interview he ever done, the subject of his ejection from Metallica came up? :|
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:09 pm PT-Misanthropic- wrote:Luncbox1 wrote:Get over it? He complains about it plenty.-Misanthropic- wrote:
Sounds about right... Dave Mustaine is one of the most devoted guys to his band I've ever seen.He writes all the songs, he sings while playing some killer riffs, and he can dish out a mean solo too.Plus, not many people could get kicked out and deserted by their best friends, far far away from home and get over it the way he did.
What else could he say when in every single interview he ever done, the subject of his ejection from Metallica came up?
Not be whiney. Say it sucked, sure, but when he talks about it he sounds whiney and annoying.[QUOTE="-Misanthropic-"][QUOTE="Luncbox1"][QUOTE="-Misanthropic-"]
Sounds about right... Dave Mustaine is one of the most devoted guys to his band I've ever seen.He writes all the songs, he sings while playing some killer riffs, and he can dish out a mean solo too.Plus, not many people could get kicked out and deserted by their best friends, far far away from home and get over it the way he did.
[/QUOTE] Get over it? He complains about it plenty. [/QUOTE]
What else could he say when in every single interview he ever done, the subject of his ejection from Metallica came up? :|
[/QUOTE] Not be whiney. Say it sucked, sure, but when he talks about it he sounds whiney and annoying.- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.
- Apr 22, 2009 6:10 pm PTLuncbox1 wrote:Not be whiney. Say it sucked, sure, but when he talks about it he sounds whiney and annoying.-Misanthropic- wrote:Luncbox1 wrote:Get over it? He complains about it plenty.
What else could he say when in every single interview he ever done, the subject of his ejection from Metallica came up?
He was just being a ****... That was Dave Mustaine.He's way over it now though.
[QUOTE="Luncbox1"][QUOTE="-Misanthropic-"]
[QUOTE="Luncbox1"] Get over it? He complains about it plenty. [/QUOTE]
What else could he say when in every single interview he ever done, the subject of his ejection from Metallica came up? :|
[/QUOTE] Not be whiney. Say it sucked, sure, but when he talks about it he sounds whiney and annoying.[/QUOTE]
He was just being a ****... That was Dave Mustaine.He's way over it now though.
- Please wait. Quick reply will be available shortly.