• On TechRepublic: Five reasons why Windows Vista failed
December 6, 2008 10:39 AM PST

Pirates of the Amazon hits the rocks

Posted by Leslie Katz
  • Font size
  • Print

The journey is over for Pirates of the Amazon, a new Firefox extension that let users illegally download movies, games, TV shows, and MP3s for free by cross referencing Amazon.com's product pages with torrent files from the Pirate Bay.

Pirate Bay/Amazon graphic

On Thursday, a day after Webware reported on the plug-in, lawyers for Amazon.com took action. They served the Internet service provider of the two students who released the extension with a take-down notice--and the students complied and removed the tool, according to The New York Times.

However, on their Web site, the students now say the plug-in was meant as an artistic parody, part of their research for a media design course at the Piet Zwart Institute of the Willem de Kooning Academy Hogeschool in Rotterdam Holland. "It was a practical experiment on interface design, information access, and currently debated issues in media culture," the students say.

And while that might seem like a convenient story concocted by the students to stay out of trouble, the NYT reports that they have backup from their teacher, Florian Cramer, who defended them on an Internet mailing list called Nettime.

Cramer said a majority of commentators failed to see the artistic nature of the experiment, and expressed concern that his students were being censored.

"With the take-down notice from Amazon.com, our students have been scared away from pursuing their art, research and learning in our institute," Cramer wrote. "We do not want a culture in which students have to preemptively censor their study because their work confronts culture with controversial and challenging issues."

While the extension was working, it showed up as a "Download 4 Free" link on the top of the Amazon product page if the content could be found on the Pirate Bay's search index. This linked directly to the hosted .torrent tracker file, letting the user avoid having to make a purchase from Amazon in place of acquiring it illegally via BitTorrent.

Leslie Katz, senior editor of CNET's Crave, covers gadgets, games, and most other digital distractions. As a co-host of the CNET News Daily Podcast, she sometimes tries to channel Terry Gross. E-mail Leslie.
Recent posts from Webware
SitOrSquat tells you where to go (literally)
Pirates of the Amazon hits the rocks
PeopleBrowsr smashes social feeds together
Free Flickr Pro over for AT&T, Verizon customers
Optimal Home Location suggests a 'greener' place to live
Can you ditch Google for a metasearch engine?
YouTube quietly launches official support for HD
Consumers have to wait for Web-based Office
Add a Comment (Log in or register) 22 comments
by rr72 December 6, 2008 11:38 AM PST
Art??? Art doesn't link directly to a torrent. There are a million other arguments that could be made but I'm shocked that a teacher would put his name on something like this. Maybe showing the extension in class instead of distributing it to millions of people is a better way of sharing "art" with the rest of the class.

The design of the tool looked great, but come on...
Reply to this comment
by nicmart December 6, 2008 7:44 PM PST
Why are you shocked? Where but in academia will you find such a high concentration of amoral idiots?
by cevantroes December 6, 2008 1:12 PM PST
Well, It succeeded in the base sense of art. It did inspire emotion. O.o However, this isn't something that should be shot down, it's not like you can't do the same thing anyway. Open two pages, and go to amazon, find a product by name, check it's review or whatever, bam, type in a search engine what your looking for and torrent, Bam it's there if it exists.Your telling me... It's ok to shutdown to people who made a program for it in class? Sure they shouldn't of released it onto the internet... but how many people do you know of who program or code, that don't? Mind you i'm not referring to professionals who are paid salaries for their code. Or whose code instantly belongs to the company they work for. All Amateur developers release their content. Anyway, by the way, the thing i mentioned about finding torrents.. that works anywhere not just amazon.... And to think someone's probably patting themselves on the back for shutting it down. Heh... Kind of like the war on drugs in the 50's. Oh no, we're failing what are we going to do?" *points at a plant* Label that a drug and burn it all down! Heh..
Reply to this comment
by EyeWierd December 6, 2008 1:14 PM PST
I think the whole "it's only a parody!" thing was a bad excuse from saying "We know, and we did: Create something that is illegal."
Reply to this comment
by humanssssss December 6, 2008 5:52 PM PST
"Creating something that is illegal." Why do you people stoop so low as to the point of "creating something that is illegal." The process of creation is an inherent innate ability of man. No man, no government shall have the right to take away a man's ability to create. The fact that a tool is available to use, does not mean of its use.

What is illegal about creating a bomb, a nuclear weapon, a gun, a knife, an add-on?!?!
by Penguinisto December 7, 2008 7:36 AM PST
Err, the extension itself is not illegal - acting on it is a civil offense, but the device itself is not.
by billybob75 December 6, 2008 2:35 PM PST
Doesn't matter, Cats out the bag now. Someone else will create a similar extension and launch it to the public. The difference will be the next person will come from an illegal torrent company that enjoys mixing it up in the legal side.
Reply to this comment
by ZetaZeta_ December 6, 2008 2:42 PM PST
Looks like I'm going to have to type a handful of characters into the Pirate Search box instead of clicking a button. It's just a simple tool. Nothing too mind blowing. In my opinion I don't think there's much problem with a free service linking a free service to another free service. (Amazon search to Pirate search).
Reply to this comment
by dng050 December 6, 2008 3:24 PM PST
It was fun, but nobody ever thought it would last.

- newspopl
http://www.newspopl.com
Reply to this comment
by SJ2571 December 6, 2008 6:42 PM PST
Still works for me here... is that because I installed the extension before it was taken offline?
Reply to this comment
by JunkSiu December 6, 2008 6:48 PM PST
Well, it never work on my machine, maybe because I am using 64 bit?
Reply to this comment
by YARRRR December 6, 2008 7:07 PM PST
http://thepiratebay.org/torrent/4552358/Pirates_of_the_Amazon_firefox_add-on

BEHOLD THE POWER OF THE PIRATE BAY!!!! :D
Reply to this comment
by JohnJ335 December 7, 2008 10:40 AM PST
http://www.mininova.org/tor/2073483

Lookie Souce code of the addon.

Now Somebody can restart this addon again :)
by paulej December 6, 2008 7:58 PM PST
One of the problems with the current laws in America is that media companies, for whatever stupid reason, are of the mind that merely linking to content is illegal. That is absolutely insane, in my opinion. But, apparently it is now the law and I guess Amazon did not want to be party to the "illegal" linking.

I wonder: is it illegal to link to a site that links to content that is illegal, like Cnet did? How many levels of indirection are required before breaking the law? :-) (I'll repeat that this is a silly law.)
Reply to this comment
by SJ2571 December 7, 2008 12:11 PM PST
Amazon is NOT party to ANY linking. Only your local view of their site is. Learn how this extension works before posting misleading BS!
by Zoobie December 7, 2008 6:43 AM PST
This isn't a problem with current laws and generating links--it's right and fair. It's akin to me taking a bunch of items illegally imported from Mexico or China, then setting up shop inside Wal-Mart. How long do you think Wal-Mart would let me stand there? Just because content is digital, doesn't mean anyone can go alter a website without the owners knowledge and redirect to a different website.
Reply to this comment
by SJ2571 December 7, 2008 12:11 PM PST
FFS, nobody has altered Amazon's website! Amazon's content has just been modified at YOUR end, not at THEIR end and not for anyone else visiting it. You make it sound as though Amazon itself has been hacked, when it actually hasn't.
by philosfool December 7, 2008 8:13 AM PST
The first sentence of this article is misleading. The extension allows users to easily find torrent files. It does not allow them to illegally download anything that they could not already illegally download. But the claim that the extension "lets them illegally download" makes it sound as if it adds this capability where it didn't exist before.

I have no doubt that what was done is illegal. It's akin to conspiracy to commit robbery.

I happen to think that this is pretty provocative art. However, whether it's art is irrelevant to whether they've committed a crime. Perhaps it is possible for a cat burglar or a con man to be an artist. Nevertheless, the fact (if it is a fact) that they're producing art does not exculpate them in the eyes of the law, nor should it. Art is often done as a form of protest. But one of the features of breaking law as protest--civil disobedience--is that you accept the consequences of your actions. It is the willingness to suffer the consequences of law breaking that demonstrates the conviction of the civilly disobedient.
Reply to this comment
by GrantPinnacle December 7, 2008 10:11 AM PST
One thing leads to another. Services like Pirate Bay are going to lead to other illegal services because as long as this exists it condones illegal activities on the net. It is costing the industry 100's of millions.
Reply to this comment
by JohnJ335 December 7, 2008 10:41 AM PST
Shutting the site down didn't work

Now I found out the source code of the addon is submitted to Mininova.

Power to the people!
Reply to this comment
by aTales December 7, 2008 1:45 PM PST
Amazon has nothing to stand on, any court in the netherlands will throw this out directly..
Reply to this comment
by 3rdalbum December 8, 2008 1:18 AM PST
I'm glad that the addon will continue to live, because it sounds like a cool concept. But I'm not buying this whole "It was just art; just a parody" excuse - it's about as plausible as "We didn't pay CD royalties to the Mormon Tabernacle Choir, because we couldn't find a contact address for them". If the addon linked to www.thepiratebay.com, then yes it would be a parody. If it linked to a search results page or a .torrent file, then it's serious.
Reply to this comment
 See all 22 Comments >>
advertisement

About Webware

Say No to boxed software! The future of applications is online delivery and access. Software is passé. Webware is the new way to get things done.

Add this feed to your online news reader

Webware topics

In the news now

Consumers have to wait for Web-based Office

Microsoft has started limited internal testing of the browser-based versions of Excel, PowerPoint, and Word, but the rest of us will have to bide our time until next year.


Energy guru to auto giants: Time for big bets

Amory Lovins, hero of environmentalists and adviser to Fortune 500 firms, says it's time for bold changes in energy and transportation, focusing first on efficiency.


advertisement

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right